Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Ofcom publishes responses to BT undertakings

Ofcom publishes responses to BT undertakings

18th August 2005 by Scott

Ofcom today published the responses to their consultation on undertakings offered by BT in lieu of a reference to the Competition Commission. The responses make interesting reading. In general the respondents welcomed the undertakings and BT’s commitment to offer the undertakings, most of the respondents felt that the undertakings needed further amendment and clarification before Ofcom should accept them. In particular respondents felt that many of the undertakings were unclear, inconsistent, and/or open to misinterpretation; and that the clauses concerning enforceability were weak as whilst allowing Ofcom to issue Directions for non compliance, they then allow BT to choose to ignore the Directions. Some of the respondents, including Energis and ITSPA felt the need to make a reference under the Enterprise Act must not be ruled out indefinitely.

Energis – BT’s biggest critic, and the company that has long argued that the break up of BT was the only way forward, and who have just been bought by Cable & Wireless had this to say:

“The draft Undertakings are not perfect. They do not remove BT’s conflict of interest – only true separation can do that – but they have the potential substantially to mitigate it. The drafting contains some ambiguities and gaps that could undermine their impact on our industry.

Ofcom will not be surprised that our major concern in the Undertakings is in relation to next generation products. Although we recognise that it may be disproportionate to require BT to implement input equivalence for some legacy products and services, it is unacceptable that the advantages inherent in its vertically integrated structure should persist across the NGN migration to give it a first mover advantage following the deployment of its NGN. It is also unacceptable that OFCOM should outline all of BT’s abuses and propose equivalence of inputs as a way of addressing this, and then anticipate stepping back from that requirement before we have any level of information or detail about 21CN.

When arguing for separation earlier this year, we said we’d be happy for Ofcom to prove us wrong by showing that its preferred option of equality of access could work. We’re satisfied that Ofcom has done so, at least on paper”.

Elsewhere the responses included:

“Significant concerns with potential problem issues and missing or unclear details, which necessitate a review of the undertakings in their current form. Tiscali’s major concern is that the undertakings may not be effective in the long run, because things are missing or inadequately dealt with, even though they are appropriate in form and intent” [Tiscali]

“It must not be the case that industry is forced to forebear with BT for a matter of years while it prevaricates and fights allegations in the Courts of breaches of the undertakings. That behaviour must be swiftly adjudged and met by a reference to the Competition Commission”. [IDT]

“ISPA members believe that true equivalence means that everyone should be able to launch products at the same time as BT retail. Current industry perception is that this is not possible due in part to the pricing processes that Ofcom are allowing BT to adopt.”[ISPA]

“In our opinion, the evidence gathered by Ofcom to date establishes that BT has in fact already abused a dominant position on a number of occasions. Ofcom should take infringement proceedings in this regard to send a signal to BT, both as punishment and as a deterrent.” [France Telecom]

“COLT is also concerned that various omissions and weaknesses apparent in the undertakings create gaps between the intentions of the Ofcom announcements from June 23rd 2005 and the actual settlement proposed” [Colt]

“Elements of the undertakings require greater clarity as the letter, not the spirit, of the undertakings will be the actual constraint on BT’s behaviour over the implementation period. The absence of structural and legal separation means that BT’s incentives to discriminate in favour of its own downstream businesses remain intact, although its ability is constrained by the undertakings” [Cable & Wireless]

All in all, the responses are no big surprise. The Other providers can see that BT has made a genuine effort to address concerns, but has still not gone far enough for most of them. Also universally the drafting of some of the clauses in the proposed undertakings and the omissions from the undertakings in areas where BT has instead given a verbal promise to behave, have been highlighted as reasons for not accepting the undertakings in their current form. The ball is now very much back in Ofcom’s court. It will be interesting to see what happens next.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in