Mark Thompson, the DG of the BBC has said that the BBC and other channels needed to rebuild viewer trust as yet another programme was added to the growing list across all channels that had misused (premium rate) phone call-ins.
The Beeb at least can claim that it doesn’t benefit financially from its phone ins unlike those on commercial stations where ‘errors’ such as picking a winner from the first five minutes of calls but continuing to ask people to call in for the next 50 (Richard & Judy) have been uncovered. Thompson, being interviewed on Sunday AM on BBC1 insisted there was no intent by the BBC to deliberately mislead the public
“Both Blue Peter and Saturday Kitchen were … serious errors of judgement. Blue Peter, a bit of blind panic on the studio floor: no intention, as far as we can tell, at all really to deceive. With Saturday Kitchen a kind of sloppiness about whether a programme was live.”
What a load of old bollocks. It’s like the Blue Peter apology itself “We would like to say sorry to you because when this mistake happened we let you down.”
Mistake makes it sound like an accident – it wasn’t. Both of these were totally aimed at deceiving viewers – these were not mistakes – people choose to do this; and “sloppiness about whether a programme was live.” What does that actually mean? It was pre-recorded show and in it it asks you to call in, but itdoesn’t tell you it is not live … that’s sloppy is it. I think a lie is the word Mr Thompson was looking for.
With ICSTIS and Ofcom both investigating all the claims made and Ofcom’s Ed Richards at least talking like a man who means business this fiasco should see a number of hefty fines coming the way of all concerned. A failure to do so would question the bottle of Ofcom and ICSTIS.