Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / PMQ’s – ID Cards

PMQ’s – ID Cards

19th January 2006 by Scott

Tory Leader took Tony Blair on over the topic of ID Cards in yesterday’s PM Question Time.

Mr. David Cameron (Witney) (Con): With rising deficits in the NHS, huge costs of pension reform and tighter pressures on public spending, how can the Prime Minister claim that spending at least £600 million a year on his ID card scheme is a good use of public money?

The Prime Minister: Because if we introduce an ID card scheme and reduce identity fraud, that makes a major difference to the costs of Government and the costs of doing business. In today’s world, if we want to tackle illegal migration, crime and identity fraud, using the new biometric technology to have ID cards is an important part of doing so.

Mr. Cameron: But we face those problems and threats today; these cards will not come in until 2013. The Prime Minister could use the money to buy 20,000 extra police officers or to have 24-hour security at our ports. Will he accept that almost every Government IT programme has massively overrun? What guarantee can he give that his estimates are right, whereas the London School of Economics, which talks about costs of £14.5 billion almost half the entire budget of the Department for Education and Skills is wrong?

The Prime Minister: First, if the right hon. Gentleman’s concern is that ID cards will not be introduced quickly enough, he should work with us to ensure that they are introduced more quickly, but that is an absurd reason for not introducing them. As for the calculations made by the LSE, I think that I am right that, although the report was put out under the LSE’s name, it was actually written by the leading campaigner against ID cards on the ground of civil liberties. So I do not think that it is an entirely objective assessment.

[ It should be noted that Davies, is only one of the report’s ‘mentors’, the other being Gus Hosein. Presumably the government is arguing that either he, plus research coordinator Dr Edgar Whitley, fourteen professors on the LSE advisory Group, in addition to the LSE’s director – who backed both original report and in the current one hoped the government would “eschew the emotive language with which they responded to the first effort” – are all politically biased, or they are all to weak and meek to stand up to Mr Davis.

After the first report was released Davis, brilliantly responded to the charge of bias by saying “I don’t hear the government condemning its own research findings that support the government because they happen to be industry biased experts on board”.]

The right hon. Gentleman should think again about ID cards, which are an important, indeed, essential way of tackling illegal migration and crime in the early 21st century. Perhaps I may put it like this: they may be the future, not the past.

Mr. Cameron: When it comes to who is working with the Prime Minister, perhaps he could answer the following question. It has been widely reported that the Chancellor does not back ID cards and would scrap them, so will the Prime Minister give a guarantee that, when the Chancellor takes over his job, the scheme will be continued?

The Prime Minister: I certainly can give a guarantee that the Government as a whole are absolutely behind ID cards, the Chancellor himself has provided the start-up costs. Why are ID cards so important now? Because we know, from all the available evidence, that identity fraud is on the increase, that is bound to happen in the modern world. Many people, including the former leader of the Conservative party, reached the conclusion that we need identity cards, and it is right to do that now because the biometric technology is coming in. Other countries are moving towards biometric passports and we will have to do that. The largest part of the cost of an identity card will be the biometric passport, which we must have. I assume that the right hon. Gentleman is in favour of the biometric passport; perhaps he could elucidate that we know that his policy tends to shift a little quickly nowadays.

We need the identity card to fight crime, illegal migration and identity fraud in the early 21st century and the costs will be largely met by the biometric passport.

Mr. Cameron: I think that I should remind the Prime Minister that these sessions are about me asking questions on behalf of the public and him answering on behalf of the Government. If he wants to switch that around, he can hold a general election. Does not he have a choice: think again or plough on with what will become a monument to the failure of big government?

The Prime Minister: I totally disagree with him. I apologise for asking policy questions but the right hon. Gentleman’s policies change so quickly almost on a day-to-day basis that sometimes it is a good idea to inform myself simply to keep up with where he is at any one time.

With the greatest respect, he should think again about the matter. We will have to introduce biometric passports. I know that he agrees with that and we will therefore have to make enormous changes in the years to come for the vast bulk of people who have passports. Identity fraud is also a major and growing problem. People throughout the world are moving towards identity card systems because they are necessary to tackle the problems of today’s world. Of course there is a cost to identity cards but there is a cost to identity fraud in so many different ways. As the argument progresses, I suspect that he will find himself in the same position as he has been on rather a lot of policies recently, from the patient’s passport to selection in schools and from the environment to social justice. I could go on; it is a long list. At the next general election, I suspect that he will be standing on his head on ID cards, as he has done on so many other issues.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in