Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Porn filters – Letter of sense

Porn filters – Letter of sense

22nd August 2013 by Scott

I notice on Twitter, that Brooke Magnanti, Laurie Penny, Zoe Margolis, Charles Stross, Jane Fae, Holly Combe, Milena Popova and Jane Czyselska have sent a letter the the Prime Minister, David Cameron about the governments network level ‘web filter’ proposals. 

Here is the letter to David Cameron about porn filtering which various writers inc me, @pennyred & @bmagnanti signed: http://t.co/PiT1tlmSXJ

— Zoe Margolis (@girlonetrack) August 22, 2013

This is a subject close to my heart as I have been writing on the issue of filtering since I started this blog, and wrote a couple of article on American attempts to regulate in the interests of ‘protecting children’ [CIPA/COPA] in Electronic Business Law.

Their letter highlights the obvious flaws with the (misguided, if well intentioned) proposals. First off the idea it mistakenly gives parents a false sense of security, and will for many be a green light that they don’t have to do anything further. It also ignores all the research on filtering which show significant levels of both over-blocking – often of the sex education and health type content highlighted in the letter – and as importantly for parents, underblocking as most are still looking at words and not pictures.

For an example of the former, I recently had personal experience of one the the world’s best selling filtering products categorising and blocking the music site Noisey. Why? Well it was classified as ‘Sex/Adult Content’. The reason? Having seen the content there was no reason, other than the fact the the company behind the site is called VICE and the URL is http://noisey.vice.com/ . This is how sophisticated these products are.

Finally, I agree with the authors of the letter that all this feels even more hollow from a government who don’ t believe in compulsory sex and relationship education for our schools. Academies and Free schools can of course already opt out of teaching what sex education there is left in the new curriculum. Asked bluntly by Lorely Burt in a parliamentary debate in April this year if he agreed that “sex and relationship education should be compulsory in all schools?”, Michael Gove waffled and obfuscated, eventually seeming to believe that saying “Simply prescribing something in the national curriculum does not mean that best practice will result” was an acceptable argument against compulsory sex and relationship education.

This is a government (and the last lot were not much better) who only want to ‘protect’ your children when there is a good sound-bite in in for them, or when middle England starts parroting the ‘outrage’ of the likes of the Daily Mail, a publication who have a website obsessed printing pictures of young girls and women in various states of undress. In these times where people think the web is full of easy to find child porn, the idea of blocking it – and indeed any other type of porn (as we like to lump them all in together in this debate) -sounds great. The problem is blocking it doesn’t get rid of it, it merely hides it away. And this government CUT the funding of the organisation, The Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre (CEOP), that tries to bring those responsible for producing and distributing the actual child ABUSE by 10% this year.

Tony Blair got it right back when he was trying to get Labour elected in 1997 when he said EDUCATION, EDUCATION, EDUCATION. Education of both parents and children (as well as some actual parenting from parents) is the best way of dealing with the issue of online legal pornography. In addition we need proper funding to organisations and police to help them remove online content (not merely hide it from prying eyes) and to actually prosecute those creating child porn. Obviously the government claim the 10% funding cut will help CEOP do a better job, because they will be more efficient. Let’s hope their website is not caught in the filters.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in