Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Power to the FCC – Brand X

Power to the FCC – Brand X

28th June 2005 by Scott

Whilst most commentators have called the Grokster ruling the most important in internet legal history, others feel the consequences of BrandX decision – at least from a US perspective are more important than those of Grokster.

In a 6-to-3 decision, Supreme Court ruled that cable companies do not have to allow rivals to offer high-speed Internet access over their systems. The court said the law on the matter was ambiguous and that the Federal Communications Commission, not the courts, had the authority to interpret it.” If a statute is ambiguous, and if the implementing agency’s construction is reasonable, Chevron (Chevron U.S.A. v. Natural Resources Defense Council) requires a Federal Court to accept the agency’s construction of the statute, even in the agency’s reading differs from what the court believes is the best statutory interpretation”

In March 2002 the FCC adopted a rule that classified cable internet services as an “information service” rather than a “telecommunications service.”

The US Telecommunications Act of 1996 definitions of telecommunications service and information service are:

(46) Telecommunications serviceThe term “telecommunications service” means the offering of telecommunications for a fee directly to the public, or to such classes of users as to be effectively available directly to the public, regardless of the facilities used.
(43) TelecommunicationsThe term “telecommunications” means the transmission, between or among points specified by the user, of information of the user’s choosing, without change in the form or content of the information as sent and received.
(20) Information serviceThe term “information service” means the offering of a capability for generating, acquiring, storing, transforming, processing, retrieving, utilizing, or making available information via telecommunications, and includes electronic publishing, but does not include any use of any such capability for the management, control, or operation of a telecommunications system or the management of a telecommunications service.

In ruling that cable internet services were an information service, the FCC was exempting cable operators from obligations to open up their networks to competitors, and make contributions to universal service funds.

Brand X, a small Californian ISP appealed this interpretation to the US Courts, and the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rejected the commission’s interpretation ruling that cable internet service, can be divided into two parts – simple data communication, which should be regulated as a telecommunications service, and more elaborate information services. As a result, it ruled that the cable companies needed to make the basic telecommunications part of their service available to rivals.

The commission disagreed, concluding that cable internet service is a single offering and that data transmission alone cannot be considered a stand-alone telecommunications service. The Supreme Court has agreed with the FCC that this is a reasonable interpretation of US Telecoms law.

Not all the Court agreed. Justice Scalia (supported by Justice Souter and Ginsburg) is his dissenting opinion accused the FCC of trying to “concoct a whole new regime of regulation” and achieved its goal by an “implausible reading of the statute”. He argues that if cable operators offer ‘telecommunications for a fee directly to the public’ then that part of their offering must be classed as a ‘telecommunications service and subject the the same regulation as competitors who offer internet access via other technologies. He goes on to argue that “Since the delivery service provided by cable (the broad-band connection between the customer’s computer and the cable company’s computer-processing facilities) is downstream from the computer-processing facilities, there is no question that it merely serves as a conduit for the information services that have already been “assembled” by the cable company in its capacity as ISP. This is relevant because of the statutory distinction between an “information service” and “telecommunications.” The former involves the capability of getting, processing, and manipulating information. §153(20). The latter, by contrast, involves no “change in the form or content of the information as sent and received.” §153(43). When cable-company-assembled information enters the cable for delivery to the subscriber, the information service is already complete. The information has been (as the statute requires) generated, acquired, stored, transformed, processed, retrieved, utilized, or made available. All that remains is for the information in its final, unaltered form, to be delivered (via telecommunications) to the subscriber”

Scalia feels that the court’s position that unless the court holds that an interpretation is the only permissible reading of a statute that it could be opening up the flood gates the agency challenges the statutory decisions that they may now be able to overturn.

Susan Crawford says: “In BrandX, Justice Thomas gets very confused about the internet and ends up essentially announcing that everything a user does online is an “information service” being offered by the access provider. DNS, email (even if some other provider is making it available), applications, you name it — they’re all included in this package. And the FCC can make rules about these information services under its broad “ancillary jurisdiction.”
This is very very big. This means that even though information services like IM and email don’t have to pay tariffs or interconnect with others, they may (potentially) have to pay into the universal service fund, be subject to CALEA, provide enhanced 911 services, provide access to the disabled, and be subject to general consumer protection rules — all the subjects of the FCC’s IP-enabled services NPRM”

Regardless of ones position on whether or not cable networks are telecoms services or not, it’s hard not to see some logic in Scalia’s position, especially on the majority view that seems to give the FCC broad scope for interpreting US law.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in