Privacy International has published a hard hitting 3 page report, Transferring Privacy and Inadequate Adequacy, setting out what it contends is the failure of the European Commission to protect the privacy of EU citizens by capitulating to US demands in approving an agreement to transfer passenger details to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. The report claims the agreement “fails to meet the interests of privacy protection”. It claims the Commission decision is part of an Agenda to weaken privacy rights in the EU to allow for a global travel monitoring system. It does nothing for the Interests of EU citizens but does help others. The report goes on … “The agreement does meet the interests of others, however.
a. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) gets access to EU airline database records even
though the DHS does not require similar access to U.S. carriers’ computer systems and records.
b. The U.S. now has data to test and implement its controversial Computer Assisted Passenger Pre-
Screening System, using European passenger data instead of American passenger data. The
European Commission believes that the Department of Homeland Security will remove this data
once testing is complete. This is an unacceptable risk taken by the Commission, and is not even part of the current agreement.
c. The European Commission is now considering the creation a centralised database of all passenger
records so that the records can then be transferred to the U.S.; creating further privacy and security concerns.
d. The European Commission wishes to see the development of EU-based laws that will grant
database access to EU member states for law enforcement purposes. The EU also wishes for access
to U.S. passenger data, but has not yet negotiated this with the Americans. There are no grounds in
American law for such transfers from U.S. carriers.
e. After establishing European surveillance laws, the European Commission is also seeking to create a global regime on passenger records surveillance through the UN agency, the International Civil Aviation Organization; thus permitting all countries to gain access to this data.
As I have written previously, there seems to me little doubt that this agreement does breach EU data protection law, and that what the US is offering is less than adequate protectio for that data which will be transfered. I also agree, in part, that there is an agenda to move towards a global travel surveillance system. This must no be allowed to happen under the pretext of protecting us from the terrorist threat. If government believe this is a good idea they should be able to argue that point on the merits of the proposal itself without mentioning 9/11 or any other event. The Patroit Act and other actions, such as the latest EU proposal on data retention show us the danger knee jerk legislation has.