“Some of my counterparts in Eastern Europe, in Spain, have experienced in the last century what can happen when government gets too powerful and has too much information on citizens”
UK Information Commissioner, Richard Thomas, hit out again against the governments plans for ID Cards, a population register planned by the Office for National Statistics and proposals for a database of every child from birth to the age of 18. (and more importantly the databases behind then, and those who will have access to the information)In an interview in the Times Thomas laid out his concerns that the combined proposals would be collecting information that was disproportionate to its purpose (and indeed with a changing purpose). With ID cards Thomas said ” “The Government has changed its line over the last two or three years as to what the card is intended for. You have to have clarity. Is it for the fight against terrorism? Is it to promote immigration control? Is it to provide access to public benefit and services? Various other reasons have been put forward . . . I don’t think that is acceptable.”
I Agree. The government’s Draft Bill is a scandal; not least because it does not give the UK citizens the right to knowe what information is being kept on them and to see it to make sure the information is accurate – a blatant disregard for basic data protection principle. Also, as I have said before, since you will still need (easily forgable) documents such as birth certificate etc to get an ID Card in the first place, it will do nothing to ‘prove’ who you are.
In a reply piece in today’s Times, Oliver Kamm criticises Thomas’ simplistic language, and accusess him of setting out to discredit the government plans “through trivial observation couched in extravagant rhetoric”
There is little doubt Thomas was over doing things a bit, but no one seems to be talking about this seriously, and the government’s ID Bill is a licence to introduce measures by secondary legislation, which need to be stopped.
Kamm does rightly concluded that being too alarmist can backfire: ” The more our public servants talk of totalitarianism without really meaning it, the less serious will that threat be taken. That really would be, as the Information Commissioner put it, “a danger, yes”.