Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Books / Stop blaming the girls: New book on sexting tries to move the conversation to consent and privacy

Stop blaming the girls: New book on sexting tries to move the conversation to consent and privacy

4th February 2015 by Scott

Sexting Panic: Rethinking Criminalization, Privacy, and Consent
Amy Adele Hasinoff
University of Illinois Press
Pub Date: Feb 15 2015

One of the joys about reading books via NetGalley is being able to perhaps read things that, whilst of interest, I might not have bothered with as a buying member of the public (this book would have been an order from the local library). I have long held an interest in the complex issue of child sexuality and in particular the – often well intentioned but often misplaced legislative – attempts made to ‘protect’ children online, and I have written about it extensively on this blog and in print [See: Filtering out child porn – smoke and mirrors? – Electronic Business Law [E.B.L. 2004, 6(10), 11-12]; Protecting children online – the COPA debate settled? – Electronic Business Law (2004) 6 EBL 7, 2; Censoring net content: the CIPA decision – Electronic Business Law (2003) 5 EBL 8, 2, and Blocking sites – America’s attempts to protect children online – Electronic Business Law (2003) 5 EBL 1, 3 ]. So, I was immediately drawn to Amy Hasinoff’ book as its starting point seemed to be one where some of the emotive baggage was lifted off to allow a rational discussion around children (anyone under the age of 18) who choose to create and share pictures of themselves that could be considered sexual in nature. She wants to challenging the fact that sexting inevitably ends up victimising young women; argues that young people’s capacity for choice should be accepted and recognised; and encourages rethinking the misplaced assumption that everything digital is public and thus fair-game.

Her views will certainly be controversial to many readers, and as she alludes to herself, they are also the type of view which politicians run away from at great speed: it doesn’t matter if you agree with her arguments, as a politician it’s ALL about appearance, and appearing to condone what many (rightly or wrongly) would see as the creation of child porn is not something any politician who wants to get elected is ever likely to come out and say. To be fair to Hasinoff, straight off the bat she admits there isn’t an easy ‘everyone’s going to love it’ solution to how we address the issue around the creation of sharing of intimate photographs by children.

That doesn’t stop her jumping right in and arguing that she would Ideally like to see child porn laws changed to take account of the age of the people involved. What she suggests is the introduction an age range for teen photo swapping that doesn’t break the law, so that a 16yr old and 14yr old consensually swapping photos of one another, for example, would not potential be prosecuted under child porn laws and face being placed on sex registers. This interested me because the situation is similar in the UK. For example, Nottinghamshire police sent a letter to local schools warning children who sexted could end up in court and or on the sex offenders’ register. And due to our own confused and non-joined up laws, what that means in practice is that 16 year olds who can legally have sex and marry could be prosecuted and put on a sex offenders register for sharing pictures of themselves doing a sexual act the law says they’re legally allowed to do. Confused yet? Put simply, even though the age of sexual consent is 16, and any sexual act would be legal, any picture of it would not be, and would in fact be classified as child pornography as the the law classes any picture that could be deemed sexual of a subject under the age of 18 as an ‘indecent image’, and thus essentially child porn – even if you take the picture of yourself.

It is comes down to consent and context. She points out that context is already present in US law in the sense that US Supreme Court ruled that cartoons, or depictions of child porn could not be classed as illegal under US law – as the law was there to protect the actual exploitation of children, not any fantasy or ‘artistic’ exploitations. Nabakov’s Lolita and many more would need to be banned, as well as a great deal of ‘classic’ art if we were to take the depiction of naked children or ‘under-age’ sex as all worthy of banning. In Hasinoff’s view the fast majority of shared photos are not actual exploitations of children, but merely children consensually exploring their sexuality. Again, not something many parents want to think their child is doing, even if they did so themselves when they were younger, as many object to the mere idea that a child (as defined in law) can consensually do anything. Children need protecting.

But it is a difficult one. If we take Supreme Court’s ‘cartoons’ decision; as a parent of a young daughter would want her to view drawings/cartoons of girls her age and above engaged in sexual acts with adults or indeed space monsters (hello japan, I’m talking to you) ? No, not really. If I had a son I’d feel exactly the same way. I personally find it all a bit creepy, but by the same token I do sympathise with logic of the argument presented by the judges of the US Supreme Court. Partly because it leads us down the path where if we are going to argue that a drawn image of an adult engaged in sexual conduct with a child is likely to make to viewer of that more inclined to act out that conduct with an actual child, then surely we have to wave the same argument over video games, where our children get to essentially become drug dealers, soldiers and mass murders? and mainstream TV and Cinema too. There are some who already think this is the case and would ban all such games, and films though the empirical evidence, to date, suggest no such link exists.

I don’t have an answer. The problem even with Hasinoff’s ‘age-range’ approach is the passage of time. If Girl A shares picture of 13 year old self with boy B, 16, and we decide that’s ok; do we still think it’s ok, when boy B is 36 and still has that photo? Perhaps guidelines for the police and judiciary would work better.

Where I am in full agreement with Hasinoff is in the double standard present it the literature and most reporting of sexting and the general swapping of sexual photos. The focus is usually on young girls. The reporting of sexting and in attitudes to trying to stop it/mitigate its effects are disproportionately aimed at young girls. In the same way female rape victims get quizzed about what they were wearing or whether they got a bit drunk, the finger pointing is often saying to women and young girls, it’s your responsibility to stop this. If you didn’t take the picture in the first place this wouldn’t have happened. Good girls don’t do this. You need to learn how to resist. You clearly have low self esteem. It’s because you’re a teenager and your hormones are out of control and you don’t know what you’re doing or understand the consequences. It was clearly peer pressure that made you do it, or the effects of our sexualised culture. Whilst it seems to be accepted that it’s natural for young boys to want to look at naked pictures of women and girls, it is somehow unnatural for a girl to either want to do the same or to create such content. And this is what we are talking about: content creation. This is clearly all patronising rubbish. Yes, clearly there are some cases were photos are taken due to peer pressure etc, but this is then inflated to stigmatise young girls as weak minded air-heads who are then portrayed as if they are the perpetrators of any subsequent action. No one seems to be worried about boys being pressured into sharing photos or doing so due to low self esteem. Why is that? A lot of the educational materials also fall foul of unduly targeting young girls and the creation of such images as opposed to highlighting the breach of privacy and the sharing of the images which is where the real crime lies.

I should say that I think education can help in making people aware of potential consequences of sharing intimate photos of oneself but at the same time I also agree that this should not be done in a manner that subjugates normal teenage urges to explore their sexuality. Like Hasinoff I feel we need to get away from this bizarre idea that private sexual images are somehow not deserving of privacy because some people seem to se their creation as nonnormative sexual behaviour. Ask most adults who have sent pictures of themselves to others want is was about and fun will usually be the reply. Why are we so quick to dismiss that as one reason for teen sexting too? So I repeat, If a teenage girl or boy shares a photo of themselves to a boyfriend/girlfriend or another friend and that person posts it online or circulates that widely to others, it is the person who has broken the trust and abused the privacy who is at fault here, not the boy or girl who created the original photo. I also think the ‘don’t do it or else’ approach to dealing with the issue is potentially dangerous. Telling teens that if a nude or explicit photo of them gets online it could ruin their career or employment prospect for life is nothing short of shaming, and more or less implying if it did happen their life is essentially over. Frankly, fuck that shit.

And this is why Hasinoff’s argument about some form of decriminalisation for sexting is important. Without it teen’s whose privacy has been abused would have no recourse to the law, because they would fear being prosecuted themselves in the process. I’m sure even here, girls would be made to feel like it was all their doing, and the ‘well, if you hadn’t sent him the photo in the first place he never could have shared around your class or posted on a 4chan board’. Thankfully some do come forward. In the UK a 14 year old boy was recently convicted of ‘revenge porn’ (the latest phrase du jour ) after he used Facebook to sell explicit photographs of his ex-girlfriend for £10. He and the person he sold the photos too were both charged with distributing photographs of a child, and possession of indecent images of a child [Both were given 12-month referral orders and must pay £100 in costs and an unspecified victim surcharge].

It is pleasing here that the victim felt she could come forward and challenge her breach of privacy, but also that she didn’t see sexting as ‘wrong’. The court was told that the girl hadn’t thought there was anything wrong with sexting her then boyfriend, but when they split up she had asked him to destroy the photographs. Again, it’s about consent. The girl had consensually sent the photos to her then boyfriend as part of their relationship, but had done so expecting a level of privacy and had then expressly requested he delete the photos when they split up. Instead he choose to share them.
Similarly, though this was with an adult, Danish journalist Emma Holten told the Guardian about her own experience of being hacked and her nude pictures being posted online. Once again it highlighted the ESSENTIAL point. It’s all about consent, dummy. Sharing or posting nude pictures of people online or via email/text/Whatsapp etc is a breach of that person’s privacy if you don’t have their consent for posting the images, it’s you who are breaking the law and should be the focus of any legal ramifications.

If I have a criticism it is that book suffers from a tendency to just repeat its main points over and over again, but then again this type of book tends to do that. It is still a well argued and provocative book that is not afraid to tackle head on changes to child porn laws or the assumption that any girl who sends explicit photo of herself is morally corrupt and at fault if that picture is then distributed by the person in whose trust she had placed her privacy.

Filed Under: Books, Law & Legal, Reviews Tagged With: books, Netgalley

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in