Ofcom’s strategic review of telecoms came to an end today (for now) with the acceptance of undertaking from BT to play nice with others and Ofcom hopes this hoped will have the effect of delivering equality of access in the fixed telecoms market. To balance this Ofcom has offered BT the carrot of looking at removing some the current regulation on BT, in areas such as the provision of retail business calls, and plans full market reviews of the retail markets in which BT has SMP in 2006/2007, at which time it may remove more obligations on BT.
BT has also agreed to set up new access services business – undertakings have been modified slightly in response to responses Ofcom received to the consultation on the draft undertakings, although I am not sure that they have been modified enough to satify those respondents that felt that many of the undertakings in the draft were unclear, inconsistent and/or open to misinterpretation. They certainly wont have changed the view that the provisions concerning enforceability were/are weak, as they still seem to allow Ofcom to issue directions for non compliance to BT, but then allow BT to ignore the directions if it wishes forcing Ofcom to then take Court action, which would no doubt be a long and draggged out process.
Ironically the first critical response to the statement on the review and BT undertakings came from the Ofcom Consumer Panel, the independent body set up to advise Ofcom on consumer interests. They said said that Ofcom’s plans to announce its consumer strategy separately later this year demonstrates that consumers are not being put at the heart of Ofcom’s work on telecoms, despite claims from Ofcom that consumers should be at the heart of such decisions. .
The Panel highlighted three key areas which if felt Ofcom has failed to address: (i) the creation of a clear set of time-specific performance indicators by which the success of Ofcom’s regulatory approach can be assessed in terms of delivery to the consumer;(ii) the need for an independent consumer champion on the new Equality of Access Board; and (iii) the appointment of an independent adjudicator to resolve quickly any practical difficulties or differences in the implementation of the agreement. The panel also remain concerned that there remains no clear indication of what the benchmarks of success will be in this process, and what Ofcom will do if the process does not work.