Times Newspapers Limited has failed in its attempt to have the decision of .eu registrar EURid to award the domain timesonline.eu to Mr Raymond M. Peddemors from Arnhem, Netherlands annulled.
Mr Peddemors, applied for the domain name timesonline.eu, during the sunrise period, based on the Benelux trademark registration TIMESON&LINE. In the view of Eurid this satisfied that he was the holder of a prior right and the accepted the application. It should be noted that the Times Newspapers Limited did not apply for the domain in the sunrise period. Which to me, was frankly a stupid move.
Not for the first time the alternative dispute resolution panel, which is provided by the Prague-based Arbitration Court attached to the Economic Chamber of the Czech Republic and Agricultural Chamber of the Czech Rep, had to decide whether Eurid was correct to award a domain based on a prior right that included an ampersand.
The Panel in this case noted, as previous panels have, that it is limited to decide on whether the Respondents (EURid) decision to register the disputed domain name is in conflict with the provisions of the Regulation, in particular Article 11 stating that: “Where the name for which prior rights are claimed contains special characters… these shall be eliminated entirely from the corresponding domain name, replaced with hyphens, or, if possible, rewritten.”
In this case, the Applicant’s mark contains the ampersand. The Applicant used the first option, stated in Article 11, and eliminated this special character entirely.
One member of the Panel was of the view that the panel should have followed the examples of Barc & elona, Fi&Ve, Col & Ogne, and Reykja & Vik, panel decisions where the panel ruled that as the ampersand corresponds to the English conjunction “and”, the transcription should form part of the domain name. In other words, there is an essential difference between the trademark Timeson&line and the domain name timesonline.eu. Accordingly, the Timeson&linetrademark cannot serve as the basis for applying for the domain name timesonline.eu but only for the domain name timesonandline.eu.
However the majority of the Panel concluded that Eurid, accepting the translitteration and registering the domain name, has complied with the .EU registration Regulation.