Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Politics / The Grass is Greener? Scotland Decides

The Grass is Greener? Scotland Decides

18th September 2014 by Scott

So it’s decision time. The People of Scotland (as opposed to Scottish people – and important, sometimes overlooked distinction) get to vote today on whether or not Scotland should break away/free of the rest of the UK and become an independent country. If the polls are to be believed it should be a close call.

I, like many living in other parts of the UK, care deeply about the vote – as we should as a Yes vote would have profound effects on England, Wales and Ireland (as well as the UK too) As with any potential separation and divorce, the children often get overlooked in the fighting and blaming (and there will be a LOT of the latter come the weekend regardless of which way the vote goes. Just so you know if it’s YES it wont be due to Negative doom and gloom stuff from the NO camp and if it’s NO, well, it was clearly all that bias BBC’s fault wasn’t it).

I care about the vote for a variety of reasons and not just because much of my family history rests in Scotland (I’ve gone back as far as the 1500 on both sides so far, so my ancestors lived in an Independent Scotland) and that I lived there for ten years of my life, including doing my secondary education there. I love Scotland , and Glasgow in particular. I wasn’t born there though and I no longer chose to live there – last doing so in 1998/9. My parents and a lot of my family, however, do still live there.

I consider myself British – so you can probably guess which way I would vote if I was still living in Scotland. I think this is because I was born in England to Scottish and English parents and grew up supporting Scotland rather than England at sports – I still do, as any friend of mine would attest. Added to that my first 30 years were almost evenly split between living in England, Scotland and Wales. They are different and yet the same. On the whole the people of Glasgow and Edinburgh have more in common with those in London, Birmingham and Cardiff (or indeed Berlin, New York or Madrid for that matter) than they do with those in Tarbet or Pitlochry. Likewise those in Tarbet probably have more in common with those in Padstow than Edinburgh.

As Billy Connolly has said “I have always remembered that I have a lot more in common with a welder from Liverpool than I do with someone from agriculture in the Highlands, although I do love them.”

That’s how I feel about Britain. I love it as a Island (esp when sun is shining). Of course if Scotland chooses independence I’ll still have Britain – it is after all the UK that would be broken up not Britain.

But what of the Vote.

Whilst the level of debate hasn’t always been great, it has perhaps been better (overall) than might have been feared at the start. Of course both sides have also talked a lot of bollocks and have also stuck their heads in the sand over questions they would rather not answer. The Yes side has probably benefited slightly more from this as the ‘Better Together’ campaign has seemingly spent more time saying what an Independent Scotland won’t have rather than highlighting benefits from maintaining our 307 year union . I sense from friends north of the border that many have felt patronised by much of the NO campaign’s tone, and I personally know a handful of people who were going to vote no who have changed their minds and will vote yes on Thursday.

My parents will both have a vote and whilst both value the concept of voting and secret ballot, neither have made any secret of their intentions to vote NO.

Of my other friends in Scotland [English, Scottish, French] they’re divided 50/50. It seems to me speaking to them that some on either side have been swayed more by the negative messages from each side rather than because they feel one option is actually better than the other. That is a shame. You should really vote FOR something rather than AGAINST something. So the Vote should be FOR an Independent Scotland or FOR a continued Union.

If I had a vote? I would vote No. I feel Scottish AND British, and to quote someone I never envisaged doing (Boris Johnson) “It’s [Scotland] a part of our being, of what makes us “us”. That certainly holds true for me.

The notion of independence is, of course, exciting, but I would also return to the opening point. The vote is expected to be very close. You could say that tells its own story. Whilst this closeness is a cause for celebration for the Yes campaign. I’m not sure how I see that being a cause the celebrate. Why? In other countries where the populace has truly craved and wanted Independence the vote has never be in doubt, it is always a landslide. This is a country still split down the middle. For that reason I don’t think enough of the people of Scotland really feel it in their bones yet. They may in another ten or twenty years time, maybe then the polls ahead of a vote will be predicting 80% or more for yes, but at the moment it’s not. This has more of a 1995 Quebec feel to it when 49.42% voted “Yes” and 50.58% “No” to make the break from Canada. Either way, tomorrow morning half the country is going to get something they didn’t vote for. Sound familiar?

Those living in Scotland will however, quite rightly, make the choice and that’d be the end of it (quite literally if it’s yes vote). The grass always LOOKS greener on the other side. Maybe it is. If the vote is Yes on Thursday it will be probably be at least a decade if not longer before we truly find out whether it is or not.

P.S. I do worry for my good friend Tom though in the case of a Yes vote. Will he still be allowed to support England in Cricket?*

P.P.S. I do like how some people don’t like being told what to do by people in Westminster but are happy to be told what to do by exPats living in California or the Bahamas.

*Note: Contrary to widespread popular opinion quite a lot of Scots do actually like cricket and we played it at comprehensive school in Glasgow.

Filed Under: Politics Tagged With: Independent Scotland, Referenda

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in