The Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) made an interesting ruling a couple of weeks ago, that slipped under the radar, but should make all lawyers sit up and take note. The lesson was how a simple misplaced piece of punctuation could lead to the scrapping of a deal
The decision concerned a Support Structure Agreement (the SSA) between Rogers Communications (Rogers Communications) Inc and Aliant Telecom Inc. (Aliant Telecom). The pair signed a deal in 2002, to string Rogers’ cable lines across thousands of utility poles in the Maritimes for an annual fee of $9.60 per pole. But early last year, Rogers was informed that the contract was being cancelled and the rates were going up. Rogers said, no, that could not happen as the parties had a deal for 5 years. Aliant said re-read the contract.
The clause in question is Section 8.1 of the SSA, which states:
Subject to the termination provisions of [the SSA], [the SSA] shall be effective from the date it is made and shall continue in force for a period of five (5) years from the date it is made, and thereafter for successive five (5) year terms, unless and until terminated by one year prior notice in writing by either party.
Aliant called the matter “a basic rule of punctuation” and the CRTC agreed calling the wording in section 8.1 of the SSA “clear and unambiguous”
“The Commission is of the view that the wording in section 8.1 of the SSA is clear and unambiguous. The Commission notes that based on the rules of punctuation, the comma placed before the phrase “unless and until terminated by one year prior notice in writing by either party” means that that phrase qualifies both the phrases “[the SSA] shall be effective from the date it is made and shall continue in force for a period of five (5) years from the date it is made” and the phrase “and thereafter for successive five (5) year terms”
Rogers’ lawyers (hopefully not to ones who drafted/signed off on the contract) tried in vain to argue the intent of the deal trumped the significance of a comma. “This is clearly not what the parties intended.” Unsurprisingly, this did not work.
There was at least some good news for Rogers. CRTC also ruled that Aliant Telecom could not assign its obligations under the SSA. Therefore, Aliant Telecom remained liable for non-performance of its obligations under the SSA until 1 February 2006, and these obligations included the obligation to provide Rogers access to NB Power poles at the rate of $9.60 per pole per year.