Adult-only porn videos and DVDs cannot be sold in the UK over the internet, by mail order or by phone in the UK, the High Court has ruled. You can buy them by these methods and have them sent to the UK, but you can not buy them from a trader in the UK. Lord Justice Maurice Kay and Mr Justice Newman said “R18” sexually explicit recordings had to be sold in person in licensed sex shops.
The case Interfact & Pabo v Environmental Health & Trading Standards Division (Liverpool City Council) involved two licences sex shop operators, Pabo Ltd and Interfact Ltd, who were convicted on 7th and 27th of April 2004 respectively of of multiple offences under section 12(1) of the Video Recordings Act 1984, namely supplying (or offering to supply) ‘R18’ videos recordings.
Under the Act a video recording cannot be supplied or offered to the public unless it has been classified by the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC).
Section 12(1) provides for enforcement of the restriction imposed by section 7(2) of the Act
“Where a classification certificate issued in respect of a video work states that no video recording containing that work is to be supplied other than in a licenced sex shop, a person who at any place other than in a sex shop for which a licence is in force under the relevant enactment (in this case the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act
(a) supplies a video recording containing the work, or
(b) offers to do so,
is guilty of an offence unless the supply is, or would if it took place be, an exempted supply”
David Pannick QC, for Interfact, argued that the ‘supply’ of the videos took place within the sex shop, when the shop accepted the order to purchase the videos from those ordering them. The Court disagreed saying the purpose of section 7(2) states that the work can not be supplied “other than in a licenced sex shop”. Indeed the BBFC R18 classification states: “Restricted. To be supplied only in licenced sex shop to persons of not less that 18 years”.
The Purpose of the classification procedure is to help guide parents and others of the suitability of various material for children. Confining the ‘event of supply’ to sex shops the court argued clearly reduces the likelihood that R18 material might be viewed by children.
The Court were equally dismissive of argument that the Human Rights Act , and in particular the ECHR’s right to freedom of expression (Article 10).
Mr Pannick argued that a prohibition on the sale of R18 videos is an unjustifyable interference with his clients freedom of expression and it was not ‘necessary in a democratic society’ because there was no pressing social need for such a restriction, especially as it was already a criminal offence to to supply an R18 video to anyone under the age of 18 years.
Mr Pannick also pointed out that many parts of the country do not have licenced sex shops, and also that it is legal to buy R18 videos from abroad via mail order, which the evidence showed was countenanced by HM Customs and Excise. The Court stated that stating that the restrictions may be circumvented did not effect the legality of the law, nor its compliance with Article 10 where the European Courts have allowed wider scope to states in regulating freedom of expression in relation to matters liable to offend public morals.
This is an odd decision, but not a surprising one. where sex and the British meet, common sense very rarely raises its head. As Mr Pannick said the Judges’ interpretation of the law would seem to be one that says it is right that adult video sellers in the Uk should be disadvantaged against those in Europe wanting to sell into this country.
Also, if a parent buys an R18 film in person or via the internet (from say Holland), and gets it mailed to him or her, he or she still owns the video. How does the means by which it got into the household protect a child from potentially seeing it?
We do have to remember that the UK is a country with an age of consent at 16, the age at which you can also legally marry, however you have to then hold on a couple of years before you can legally rent, or buy, a video showing other adults having consensual sex, or buy a sex education video.
It used to be even more stupid. Although the R18 category was introduced in 1982, it wasn’t until around 2000 that the sale of what most would term ‘hardcore’ pornography would actually get this classification, until then it was edited ‘softcore’, so no matter what age you were you could not legally buy a hardcore video in the UK.
We take the same approach to adult satellite channels. We need to protect the children so letting encrypted channels licenced in the Uk show hardcore porn is just not allowed, in fact you can lose your licence for broadcasting it.
It seems strange in a world where anyone, children included, can easily find (especially via p2p) and download hardcore porn from the internet that the UK still try to ‘protect’ the children offline in ways that do not seem to make sense to any sane person. There again, may I am just not sane.
Just as well we’re protecting the children.