The UK government eventually released its green paper on the future on the BBC today, and on first viewing it looks like being a result for the BBC with the government shying away from any of the major overhauls suggested by independent reports.
The Green Paper on the future of the BBC looks at all aspects of the BBC – from its programming and funding to its governance and regulation and its accountability to the public. The proposals and options contained in the Green Paper have been informed by the results of our initial phase of consultation and research, as well as by the series of seminars chaired by Lord Burns and his panel, and their advice to the Secretary of State.
With regards to the future governance of BBC, the green paper agreed that structural change is necessary to end the dual role of the BBC Governors as regulators and champions of the BBC and to preserve BBC independence from political interference. The government however rejected the idea put forward by the Burns report of a model of governance with a BBC Board plus external regulator, the Public Service Broadcasting Commission (PSBC). The government argue that the PSBC would fail to provide clarity and distance from government.
The current board of Governors is to be replaced by a new, transparent and accountable and independent BBC Trust to oversee the corporation – with ultimate responsibility for the licence fee and for making sure the BBC fulfils its public service obligations. Michael Grade will be the first chairman of the BBC Trust. An executive board, lead by current Director General, Mark Thompson, will manage the day to day running of the BBC and will be accountable to Trust.
Other key proposals in the Green paper include: (i) BBC will continue to be established by a Royal Charter the next one should last for 10 years; (Ii) a continuation of the licence fee as the means of funding the BBC. The level the fee will be set at will be looked at in 2007; (iii) there will be a review of whether there is a case for other methods of funding the BBC – particularly subscription – before the end of the next Charter period, most likely around the time of digital switchover; and (iv) an examination around 2010/2012 to look again at whether to ensure plurality that some of licence fee/funding income should be provided to other Public Service Broadcasters (PSB), such as Channel 4.
The Green paper also recommends sharpening of the BBC’s remit by introducing five distinctive purposes that all BBC services should aim to fulfil: sustaining citizenship and civil society, promoting education and learning, stimulating creativity and cultural excellence, representing the UK, its Nations, regions and communities, and bringing the UK to the world and the world to the UK.
In Parliament, the shadow culture secretary, John Whittingdale, whilst welcoming the majority of the green paper proposals expressed disappointment that the Trusties would still part of BBC, so would not be independent, and would still not provide the confidence that an external regulator, such as that recommended by Lord Burns would bring to enforce BBC actions. They were also disappointed that the green paper rejects opening up the BBC’s books and spending to the National Audit Office, to hold them to public account and justify value for money.
The BBC welcomed the Government’s proposals, with Michael Grade stating “”The Government’s decision to opt for its new Trust model heralds the biggest change in the governance of the BBC in 77 years”.