Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / UK Govt prefers status quo on journal ‘open access’ question

UK Govt prefers status quo on journal ‘open access’ question

8th November 2004 by Scott

The UK Government published its response to the UK Science and Technology Committee’s report on open-access scientific publishing today, and it seems the government is not keen to change the staus quo. “The government’s approach is to facilitate a level playing field so that the market can develop without any institutional barriers being put in the way of any particular publishing model”

Whilst the government’s response endorses much of the Committee’s Report “in principle”, it seems unwiling to do anything concrete to help, and in other areas seems to be saying there is no problem to begin with, describing the current scientific publishing industry as “healthy and competitive” and saying it “is not aware that there are major problems in accessing scientific information”.

This position interestingly goes against that of the Committee in its report but also the government funded Joint Information Systems Committee (JISC) which states that it has “already identified the need for change in the scientific publishing model in order to improve access and has been funding projects and reports to stimulate change”. The Committee reply that they “are not convinced that ignoring the position of an expert body in this way is in the best interests of the scientific community in particular, or the public in general. It is certainly not a good example of evidence-based policy making”.

The Committee is equally scathing of the government’s stance on the ‘author-pays model’; which the committee recommended needed further investigation to assertain whether it could be used at all. The Government response argues against the wholesale adoption of the author-pays publishing model as if this is what the Committee had firmly recommended as the only alternative to the current situation. The Committee calls this interpretation “a deliberate misunderstanding, if not a misrepresentation, of the Committee’s Report”

The Committee concludes by stating: “We are disappointed that the Government has missed the opportunity to take more decisive action in response to our Report. We recommend that the Government reconsider its position on this important issue in the light of the other responses to our Report published here; the forthcoming RCUK policy on the publication of, and access to, research outputs; and in view of the support for the Committee’s stance from the Wellcome Trust, an important research funder. In this context, we do not believe that Government should continue to refuse to provide the modest funds necessary to make institutional repositories workable, and to allow the experimentation necessary to properly test the feasibility of the author-pays publishing model”.

It seems a shame that the Government is apparently unwilling to look at this issue more seriously, and that it has both apparently mis-read the original report and ignored any evidence that the current system is not the most effective. But, no doubt the publishers will be happy …

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in