Remember Napster? The illegal version that is? Well, the court cases connected to it are still ongoing, in particular a lawsuit filed in summer 2003 by Universal Music Group and EMI against venture capital firm Hummer Winblad Venture Partners and Bertelsmann for their investments in Napster.
The suit alleged that both defendants knew Napster was giving its users a means to infringe on copyright works, and were essentially profiting from it.
Hummer Winblad, filed a counterclaim and copyright misuse defence alleging that UMG and EMI violated the law by making false statements to the Justice Department (DoJ) during its 2001 antitrust investigation of the major label’s online music joint ventures, Pressplay and MusicNet, and by their refusal to licence legal music to Napster and other online music distributors.
The DoJ abandoned its investigation in December 2003 finding no evidence of
wrongdoing.
Hummer Winblad have argued that white papers provided by the companies to the DoJ were known to be false or contain misleading statements especially concerning the labels’ most favoured nations (MFN) licensing clauses, the effectiveness of the firewalls put in place between the labels and their joint ventures, and the fact that UMG selectively redacted nonprivileged documents in an attempt to hide the first two charges.
In a memorandum and order filed on Friday 21st April Marilyn Hall Patel granted Hummer Winblad’s request that the companies produce all previously withheld communications related to the DOJ’s antitrust investigation to the Court within 30 days.
In reaching her decision, Judge Patel found that UMG’s assertion that licences granted showed a “wide dispersion” or terms was fundamentally incompatible with its practice of including MFN clauses in all its licensing agreements. As such she concludes that the disparate licensing argument is arguably entirely false, and is certainly highly misleading and that the Court finds “reasonable cause to believe that the attorney’s services were utilized in furtherance of the ongoing unlawful scheme”
Judge Patel also found that evidence showed that contrary to claims made in their white papers to the DoJ both UMG and EMI were fully aware of the terms of content licences between PressPlay and MusicNet and third parties. Judge Patel therefore found enough evidence of alleged fraud is the preparation and submission of the two White Papers to the DOJ to find that the crime-fraud exception to attorney-client privilege to the case.
“The White Papers reflect the culmination of the labels’ efforts to bring closure to the DOJ antitrust investigation, and are presumably based on extensive investigation into the dealings between the joint ventures and their label parents. UMG and EMI are therefore ordered to produce all previously withheld communications related to the DOJ’s antitrust investigation, including but not limited to the following:
(1) internal investigations of the relationship between the labels
and the joint ventures, including the disclosure of competitively sensitive
information;
(2) communications made in the course of preparing the White Papers;
(3) other communications concerning what information and documents
should be produced to the DOJ.”