Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Victory for BT? or Everyone?

Victory for BT? or Everyone?

24th June 2005 by Scott

The UK communication regulator Ofcom issued a statement yesterday that the Ofcom Board has accepted a Board of BT Group’s offer – in principle – to legally binding undertakings in lieu of a reference under the Enterprise Act, to help solve `enduring economic bottlenecks` such as the local loop, and ensure continued competition in the fixed line market. In Ofcom’s phase 2 report in the strategic review of telecommunications it recommended an approach of securing from BT ‘real equality of access’. Ofcom is now satisfied that proposals forwarded by BT can achieve this aim through the creation of a new access services division which will be a functionally separate division of BT, with its own distinctive brand, which will deliver a compressive suite of access products including local loop (LLU) and wholesale line rental (WLR) to wholesale customers – including BT Retail – equally. BT has also committed to providing equivalence of output for legacy products such as: (i) LLU – ready for service June 2006; (ii) WLR on the PSTN – ready for service mid 2007, migration complete June 2010; (iii) WLR on ISDN2 – ready for service September 2007, migration complete end-March 2009; (iv) WLR on ISDN30 – ready for service December 2007, migration complete December 2009; (v) IPStream – ready for service end-December 2005, migration complete end-December 2006; and (vi) Wholesale Ethernet Service ( WES), and Backhaul Ethernet Service (BES) – ready for service September 2006, migration complete March 2007. BT has separately committed to using its best endeavours to have WLR equivalence of input ready for service by the end of 2006, with a financial rebate to operators if that deadline is not met. BT has also committed to resolve outstanding issues for other products where it has significant market power such as carrier pre-selection, partial private circuits and ATM interconnection. BT has also addressed the question of the relationship between BT Wholesale and BT Retail, by providing greater clarity on the organisational separation of governance of these business units and will separate out those product management teams in BT wholesale which provide SMP services from non- SMP services. The creation of an Equality of Access Board will cover compliance with the undertakings across the whole waterfront of SMP products. This will have five members, three of whom will be independent, and a BT non-executive board director who will chair the EAB – providing a direct link in terms of accountability to the BT Group Board. It will have independence. Finally, BT’s undertakings will set out some clear principles on which BT will base its future design, procurement and roll-out decisions for the 21st Century Network. These include: BT to ensure that the 21CN design supports competition, by allowing other operators unbundled access to key bottlenecks; to design the 21CN in a way which will support Equivalence of Input; charges to reflect a network that is efficiently designed for the above purposes; and to launch retail products only when equivalent wholesale products are available. The full undertakings – which will be subject to final consultation – will be published on 30 June, together with a number of other proposals relevant to securing greater competition in the fixed line market They will be legally binding and enforceable, and will mean that: in the event of a breach, Ofcom could take the matter to the High Court. The Board of BT Group plc would then be responsible for ensuring compliance with the order of the Court; third-parties affected by a breach could also seek damages via the Court to recover losses incurred; and these undertakings will sit alongside Ofcom’s existing competition and regulatory power.

It is hard not to see this as a victory for BT in the short term – one only has to look at how happy their CEO is to see this is a good result for the company. However, BT’s rivals also cautiously welcomed the deal. A spokeswoman for Energis said the company remained in favour of a full break-up of BT’s retail and wholesale arms but added: “We’re optimistic that Ofcom has achieved a settlement that resolves important issues about the structure and incentives of BT.”

Michael Harrison in the Independent thinks this just delays the eventual break up of the company; Roger Darlington (IWF and Ofcom Consumer Panel) said “The challenge now is not so much to BT, which knows what it must do and shows every sign of being willing to do it. The real challenge now is to BT’s competitors. For years, they have complained that they do not have a ‘level playing field’ and therefore cannot compete effectively against BT. Now they have a level paying field. Now there are no excuses. Consumers will want to see significant new infrastructure investments and the provision of products and services which are cheaper, faster, more innovative” Over at EuroTelcoBlog James Enck says “Most of the key elements are along the lines of what BT itself proposed back in February, though a few elements of the fine print lead me to think that this is a fairly tough settlement for BT, perhaps reflecting the company’s desire to cooperate in order to avoid more serious intervention”, whilst Russ at Ofcomwatch said “I think what happened today with Ofcom’s announcement of its settlement with BT over access to BT’s network exposes some weaknesses in the EU / UK regulatory framework for telecoms. It seems that Ofcom’s ex ante telecoms regulatory powers are quite weak and that the regulator essentially had to use its Enterprise Act referral powers to extract concessions from BT.”

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in