Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / When the chips are down – lie to the court

When the chips are down – lie to the court

8th August 2007 by Scott

All publicity is good publicity, a wise (?) man once said. I’m not sure Heller Ehrman and Day Casebeer Madrid & Batchelder will be thinking that after getting a stern dressing down by San Diego federal Judge Rudi Brewster.

Brewster issuing an opinion in case between mobile phone chip markers Qualcomm and Broadcom wrote “by clear and convincing evidence that Qualcomm counsel participated in an organized program of litigation misconduct and concealment throughout discovery, trial and post-trial before new counsel took over the lead role in the case on April 27, 2007”

He added “Qualcomm’s lead and co-counsel up to the time Qualcomm substituted new lead counsel, who adamantly denied the obvious and then, when the truth was discovered and exposed by document production, sequentially contended denial of relevance, justification, mistake, and finally non-awareness.”

Kick them when they’re down? Ok. “Qualcomm counsel’s indefensible discovery conduct belie counsel’s later implied protestation of having been ‘kept in the dark’ by their client.”

It has to be said that Qualcomm themselves didn’t get off any better. Judge Brewster pointed to Qualcomm’s “constant stonewalling, concealment and repeated misrepresentations” during discovery, and scolded the company’s “presentation of numerous witnesses who steadfastly testified falsely” stating there was “clear evidence that Qualcomm, its employees and its witnesses actively organised and/or participated in a plan to profit heavily by (1) wrongfully concealing the patents-in-suit … and then (2) actively hiding this concealment from the Court, the jury, and opposing council during the present litigation”.

The case, brought by Qualcomm in October 2005, alleged that Broadcom products complying with the international H.264 digital video compression standard infringed two Qualcomm patents. In January 2007, a unanimous jury found that Broadcom did not infringe the patents, and further recommended that the court find that Qualcomm misled an industry standards-setting body known as the Joint Video Team (JVT)  by failing to disclose the patents related to the H.264 standard. The JVT was set up by sub-groups of the ITU and ISO.

Pre-trial, during the trial and post trial Qualcomm unequivocally asserted that it had not participated in any way in the JVT until after May 2003, when the standardization of the first version of H.264 was completed. This was revealed to be untrue by documents (over 200,000 pages of emails, memoranda, and other company documents) produced post-trail which in the words of Judge Brewster “directly and unequivocally exposes as blatantly false Qualcomm’s steadfast assertions at summary judgement, during trail, and at the post trail hearing on waiver and inequitable conduct that it did not participate in the JVT until after May 2003”.

How far did Qualcomm go? Well at least three employees who had been involved in the JVT going back to January 2002 suffered group amnesia on the stand and all denied they or Qualcomm had anything to do with the JVT until after the standard had been approved.

The Court ruled that by not revealing its IPR to the JVT that Qualcomm had waived its rights to enforce its patents and their continuations, continuations in part, divisions, reissues, or any other derivatives of either patent. It also ordered Qualcomm to  pay all Broadcom’s litigation fees, which David Rosmann, vice president of intellectual property litigation for Broadcom, said could be around $10 million. The judge is expected to issue a ruling in the next couple of weeks on possible sanctions against Qualcomm and its lawyers.

Qualcomm responded to the judgement saying it “respectfully disagrees with the court’s findings” and intends to appeal them.”Qualcomm acknowledges the seriousness of the court’s findings and reiterates its previous apology to the court for the errors made during discovery and for the inaccurate testimony of certain of its witnesses,” the statement read.

Ah yes, the I know we lied on a mass scale – under oath – but you’re still wrong, your honor, defence. I can see that one working.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in