With the ever growing number of personal ‘start pages’ out there at the moment, and with the ability of these to play a growing role in the distribution and adoption of RSS, I thought I’d have a look at a few and see if the ‘killer’ start page is out there yet. Here are my random thoughts (as opposed to detailed examination) on the contenders: –
Currently my ‘Start Page’ of choice.
Great searching options of Google/Yahoo/Icerocket/Wikipedia. Email modules for Gmail, Yahoo, and Pop email. It has a good bookmarks module – although you do have to add each one individually. However, it does let you add tags to the bookmarks which is great.
Other modules/Widgets include:
- Weather
- Writely Docs
- To-Do
- Ical
- Del.icio.us
- Blogmarks
Adding feeds and importing OPML files is easy. Reading feeds is also good, with content displayed in a nice clean two pane floating box with post title on the left and post content on right. Clicking on the ‘Read All’ option allows you to scroll all the posts from that feed in the right hand pane.
Easy to use, and I like the look and feel.
Microsoft’s entry into the start-page arena is – as you’d expect – the one that will probably end up with the most users, regardless of whether or not it is the best. However, even in beta ‘Live’ has a lot going for it. Of course you need to have an MSN/Hotmail Account to use the service, and the only mail you can view on it is currently your Microsoft email account.
Searches are confined just to MSN at the moment. It is nice is that you can save searches to your ‘Live’ page – and it saves it with tabs for web/news/feeds. I like this.
The ability to display the content in 1, 2, 3 or even 4 columns is great
‘Live’ allows you to import or export your feeds to and from the system using an OPML file. You can then choose which feeds to add to your page. You full list of feeds is always available to you just by clicking on add content, which displays a handy sidebar which you can keep dispayed or hidden. If you click on more next to any feed item a small box pops up with a preview of the item, and gives you further option to read full story, send to a friend and blog this. There is also a read all option for each module too.
Microsoft’s add-on’s page is Microsoft Gadgets.
- Soduku puzzles
- Google search
- To-Do
- Ebay search
- Notes
- Tv listings
- Gmail preview
Also once you’ve added a module/feed/ gadget just try and edit it. You can’t. So if you keep getting ‘
Oops, we seem to be having a problem with this feed. Please try again later’ messages and I do a lot on ‘Live’. You either have to hope it sorts itself out or delete and re-add the module. Not good.I like ‘Live’ a lot. When Microsoft try, and when they allow other to play (creating ‘gadgets’) they come up with some good things. Also intergration with the rest of the ‘Live’ offerings make this attractive, esp if you have a MSN/Hotmail account. ‘Live’ Mail and Calendar can already be added and IM is coming soon.
I really have no idea what the purpose of Google IG is.
It has set 3 column lay out. You can drag stuff into 1 or 2 columns, but the page doesn’t change to fill this space. You of course get Google search, a Gmail module, Weather etc.
Google’s (unofficial) add-ons page is Google Modules (so no mention of this on the site)
- Yahoo Mail (allows you to read this mail within the module)
- To-Do
- Weather
- Bookmarks
- Zoho Writer Docs
Personally I find the Google offering the worst of those I have looked at. It is not very user friendly and looks horrible. I would actually prefer not to have a start page if this in its current form was my only option. I like Google, but I do wish at times they’d spend less time trying to enter every market available and spend a little more time actually improving things they already have / or bought – Google IG and Blogger being prime examples.
Well, this is certainly different. Going more for a desktop feel, Groowy is something I like the idea of.
The Search option allows you to search Google, Yahoo, Icerocket, Technorati, and Wikipedia.
Adding feeds is easy, although you can only add them individually, no OPML options.
With feeds, you just get the headlines, with a floating box offering more information if you hover-over with your mouse. Clicking on any headline brings up the two pane floating box with post title on the left and post content on right. Unlike other employing this option they also include a bookmark in del.ico.us button, which I like.
What I do like about Goowy is that you can download your contacts from Yahoo, Gmail, Hotmail, and MSN. You can get pop access to your email acount of all of the above, plus a custom option too. There is also a simple but effective Calendar. If you like playing games – especailly old arcade games, you can play those too through Groowy – hard to beat a few games of space invaders!
Their widgets (minis) include:
- To-Do
- Del.icio.us
- Flickr
- Stocks
I will certainly keep an eye on this one.
Unlike the other in this review, protopage allows total free positioning of modules/widgets so you can position widgets anywhere on the screen, and even allow widgets to overlap. although they have also recently introduced a ‘fixed’ option too, that works more like the other reviewed here.
The search option lets you search Google, Yahoo, Wikipedia and Dictionary.com; but if you want to edit the HTML you can pretty much get it to search whatever you want. The ability to edit the HTML of any module, means that if you are so inclined you can also personalise things even more.
Adding feeds is easy, as is importing OPML files. One thing I quite like is that you can have all you feeds in one module if you so desire, which you can scroll down.
Modules/Widgets are limited to:-
- Bookmarks (have to enter them manually)
- Add photos
- Email (support for Gmail, Pop and IMAP)
I like what they are trying to do here, but Protopage just looks a bit naff and like a school project to me, when put up against the others.
Pageflakes has a nice look to it, using a nice tabbed approach to allow you to create pages for specific purposes, such as Work, Reading, Fun, etc. It allows you to add more pages as you need them. The pages work on a three column drag and drop approach, and have 42 modules/Widgets to choose from at the moment to add to your pages including:
- To-Do
- Notes
- Zoho Writer Docs
- Dictionary
- Gmail inbox displayer
- Chat client
- Weather
- iCal Viewer
- Address Book
- Flickr photo display
- delicious tag cloud
The web search box, gives you a choice to have Google, Ask, Yahoo or MSN as your default and allows you to search web/news/images [This would be better if the search was tabbed to change between searchengines].
Adding new feeds is easy, with the site offering autodiscovery of any feeds if you type in a url, and you can also import your OPML file in, and have all your feeds on your pages if you so desire (although the inport OPML wasn’t working for me).
Pageflakes have decided to follow Netvibes’ lead on displaying content from feeds, by doing so in a nice clean two pane floating box with post title on the left and post content on right. What is missing that Netvibes’ implementation has is the ability to read all, and be able to scroll the content of all the content of a particular feed in this right hand pane.
I think PageFlakes has a great deal of potential. And it’s the first one of these pages I have seen with an IM client.
Favoor sells itself more as an online bookmark manager, and allows you to import your bookmarks from IE, Firefox, Safari, and Opera, creating a module for each Folder. Once created you can then add new links to any of the module/folders. [It is worth noting that if you have a lot of bookmarks this causes problems for Favoor, which only allows you to import a file of 100kb – my firefox one is 163kb]
Favoor allows you to add and read rss feeds too. There is no option for importing or exporting OPML, so you have to add items individually. You just get the headlines, with a floating box offering more information if you hover-over with your mouse. All links open in a new window to the source material.
With no Widgets aside from ‘notes’ this is really the poor mans choice of start pages, although the import bookmark function is certiainly one I would like to see some of the other start pages offer – although done better, as Favoor doesn’t cope with long titles that wrap around one line, resulting in them falling outside the ‘module’.
Now, this is sort of a cross between Live and Netvibes – which on the face of it is not a bad idea.
It has a search box, but what it is searching is unclear.
Adding new feeds is easy. It has autodiscovery of any feeds if you type in a url. It also allows you to import OPML files. With feeds, you just get the headlines, with a floating box offering more information if you hover-over with your mouse. Clicking on any headline brings up the two pane floating box with post title on the left and post content on right. What is missing, as with Pageflakes, is the Netvibes option to read all, and be able to scroll the content of all the content of a particular feed in this right hand pane.
Web Notes and Weather are the only widgets at the moment.
With more widgets this could be ok, but at the moment there are better options.
Conclusion
The Killer ‘start page’ doesn’t exist yet, but most of the ingedients are conatined in the current offerings. My personal choice? With some venture capital secured, I am going to stick with Netvibes for the moment, although Pageflakes is not far from winning me over, and I think these two may just about be able to stay in the game with the big boys. Groowy too, I think has a future. I am less sure of the others (MS and Google aside). I think ‘Live’ is certainly going to attract users, and if you’re an MS world kind of person I can see little reason not to use it.
| What Can I do with | Netvibes | Windows Live | Favoor | Google Personalised | Groowy | Protopage | Pageflakes |
Eskobo |
| Search | x[Google/ Yahoo/ Icerocket/ Wikipedia] |
x [MSN] | x [Google/ Favoor] |
x [Google] | x [Google/ Yahoo/ Icerocket/ Wikipedia/ Technorati] |
x [Google/ Yahoo/ Wikipedia/ Dictionary.com] |
x |
x |
| Columns / View |
3 |
1-4 |
3 |
3 |
floating |
3 |
3 |
|
| Read/Preview Email | x[gmail/ Yahoo/ Pop] |
x[Hotmail/ Live Mail] |
x[gmail] | x |
x [gmail/Pop/ IMAP] |
x [gmail] |
||
| Calendar | x [Live Calendar] |
x |
||||||
| Contacts/Address Book | x [via Hotmail/Live email] |
x |
x |
|||||
| Tasks/To-Do | x |
x | x |
x |
x |
|||
| Notes | x | x |
x |
x |
x |
|||
| Bookmarks | x |
x [can add your IE favourites as ‘Live favourites’] |
x |
x |
x |
|||
| Read Feeds | x | x | x | x | x |
x |
||
| Import/Export Feeds | X | x [Both import and export features] |
x |
x |
||||
| Weather | x | x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
|
| IM | x [coming soon] |
X [Coming Soon] |
x |
technorati tags: start pages, netvibes, pageflakes, protopage, Windows Live, Groowy,
Google Personalised, Eskobo







