Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Whither The Legal Web – a half time report

Whither The Legal Web – a half time report

4th July 2005 by Scott

It has taken me a few weeks to find time to sit down and read through the part one (chapters 1-5) of Whither the Legal Web.

Whither, is an e-book, put together by Delia Venables (who’s site must be one of the most bookmarked by law librarians) and Nick Holmes (a very savvy legal writer, and publishing consultant) , which seeks to review current developments on the UK online legal landscape.

Part 1: Legal Information
· The Law
· Government, Parliament and Justice
· Scotland and Wales
· Legal Information Services
· The Web

Right at the start of the book Nick Holmes makes the valid point that accessing the law in this country on the web is not great – not comprehensive, not ‘joined -up’ etc. He highlights that as the people who are governed by these laws we should have easy access to those laws that effect us. In looking at ways this can be achieved the first chapter looks at the work done by Legal Information Institutes such as the British and Irish Legal Information Institute (BAILII) who are working to enable access for all to all the UK’s primary law through a common interface, free at the point of delivery. Also mentioned is the UK government’s planned statute law database, which aims to provide online access to all the UK’s statutes.

Indeed just yesterday in the House of Commons written answers Gordon Prentice MP got an answer to the following question he had asked: “To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry if he will take steps to make all Acts of Parliament published before 1988 for which his Department is responsible available online”.

Alan Johnson replied: “The Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office (HMSO) within the Cabinet Office is the Queen’s printer of Acts of Parliamentary, and responsible for the publication of Acts of Parliament. HMSO has considered the publication of Acts prior to 1998, which is the earliest date when these were available electronically, but has decided not to do so as many have been heavily amended and to publish them in their original form would be misleading for many users. The Government are, however, taking forward development of a statute law database which will contain the fully 4 Jul 2005 : revised and updated text of all legislation from 1275. It is expected that this will be made available to the general public during 2006”.

Sue Pettit has written a good overview of the EU’s Europa site and flags up the stupidity of both the EU parliament (OEIL) and the EU Commission (Pre-Lex) maintaining legislative tracking databases. Her introduction to EUR-Lex (the main access point to EU law) which she says “could become the exemplar official legal website” is a highlight of Chapter One.

One of my few disappointments with the first part of this book came in Chapter Two, and surprisingly from Delia Venables. In her good overview of the UK Parliament and how to find information produced by Parliament, she mentions one site that tries not to provide a different route into accessing this information ePolitics but seems to have totally overlooked what I have felt has been the best political site of the last year, and the best way of searching what is said in parliament – They Work for You. This is one case where if I was producing Hansard I would just hire these people to deliver the material to the public. Easy to use, user friendly, colourful (still a few glishes, but, it is still in beta). I hope the oversight of TWFY ommission is rectified in any future update.

My education of the Scottish legal system that I picked up as a youth was refreshed by a the article by QC Jonathan Mitchell; and Marie Navarro and Carolyn Kirby do the Welsh proud with their contributions to access to law in the principality.

Chapter Four, looks at legal publishing and Anne Hemming’s article ‘What’s new in Legal Publishing’ found me nodding quite a lot. She points out – mentioning Richard Susskind (didn’t you just know he’d get in there somewhere!) – that with the growth of clinet facing products and marketing techniques, that most law firm have become publishers.

Consolidation of the legal publishing market and the extension of elctronic products has been a key theme in recent legal publishing. She covers recent developments such as moves by some legal publsihers such as Lawtel, who have moved to differentiate themselves from other providers, by offering its legislation calendar current awareness service (Factiva’s current flirtation with RSS would be another example of this); and more niche publishers such as PLC who offer – what she sees as an increasing trend – ‘white branding’ of content to allow law firms to embed PLC into Knowhow systems etc (of course, cancel your subscription …)

The Final Chapter of part one covers the web, with an overview of key web technologies such as the browser, Blogs, Wiki’s, search engines, and RSS. Nick Holmes does a great job of providing a clear and basic (although I would like to see some of this material expanding) overview of just what these things are and provides a few simple tips. This is further backed up with a look at one of my favourite blogs, Jeremy Phillips and ILanah Simon’s IPKAT.

I hope ‘Whither’ will be an organic and changing – hopefully frequently updated work – once completed. At the half way stage this looks like a good primer text for lawyers and Information staff alike.

I should mention here, that Nick is kind enough to mention this blog in the blog article. I would also like to thank him for giving me access to review part one. Many thanks Nick.

One of the aims of this book is to educate lawyers, and there are 5 CPD points up for grabs for each part for either the Law Society or the Bar Council scheme. The questions are set and marked by Delia Venables.

Further Publication details

Part 1 was published 10 May 2005; Part 2 will be published in September 2005.
Each Part costs £40 + VAT; purchase both Parts now for £60 + VAT.
Multi-use licences cost £100 + VAT each part; £150 + VAT for both.
Up to 5 people may earn CPD points under the multi-use licence

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in