The WIPO arbitration panel has turned down a request by Geoffrey Inc (Owners of Toys R Us) to have the domains pensareus.com and pensrus.com transferred. Geoffrey have registered over 250 domain names incorporating the ‘R’ US and ‘Are US’, and have recently registered the domain names pensrus.net, pensrus.org, pensrus.info, pensrus.net, pensrus.org, pensrus.info and pensrus.biz.
PENSRUS is a web based owned by Henry Morgan, which was established in 2001 and sells customised pens – with messages or promotional logo’s etc included on the pens. For Many years prior to starting the website Mr Morgan used the freephone number 1-800 PENSRUS to market and sell his pens.
Geoffrey, arguing the registration and use of the domains is confusingly similar to their own, put up the usual set of objections to the domains, arguing that Not The Usual on behalf of Mr Morgan had registered and used the domain in bad faith to (i) knowingly confusing the public, (ii) dilute and tarnish their “R” US Family of Marks and (iii) diverting prospective purchasers from their websites to Mr Morgan’s; and (iv) preventing them from reflecting its marks in corresponding domain names
The Panel agreed that as the arbitration panel proceedings can not take into account outside factors, such as marketplace evidence, that the fact the domains included the registered trade mark R US and ARE US in full lead to the conclusion that they were confusingly similar to the a trademark or service mark to which Geoffrey holds the rights. Despite this, the Panel dismissed the complaint arguing that the purpose of the dispute proceedings is not for resolving trademark infringement/trademark dilution disputes, but for clear cases of cybersquatting. In this case they found no evidence of cybersquatting. Mr Morgan runs a legitimate and well established business, with over 40,000 customers; filed an application for the registration of a service mark in relation to its online business in 2001 (Geoffrey filed an opposition to the trademark application in 2003); and does not operate a business in a market that Geoffrey operates in.
According to the panel the courts were the correct venue for deciding on possible trademark issues, as such it was unnecessary to decide if the domains had been registered in bad faith.
Reading the decision I got the feeling that the panel were less than impressed that Geoffrey had shown no evidence that they used the terms pensrus /pensareus as trademarks, and the additional fact that they had no interest in the domains until Mr Morgan applied for a service mark, at which time they preceded to register the domains pensrus.net, pensrus.org, pensrus.info, pensrus.net, pensrus.org, pensrus.info and pensrus.biz.
It will be interesting to see whether Geoffrey now go after Mr Morgan through the courts. If I was them, I would not bother, unless they are suddenly planning to enter to pen supply market in a big way that is.