ICANN’s Board of Directors has voted 9 to 5 against a proposed agreement for a .XXX. Sponsored Top Level Domain (sTLD). The application was proposed by the ICM Registry.
ICANN’s chief, Paul Twomey, said the decision was not political. “The heart of the decision today was not driven by a political consideration.” Maybe ICANN believe that, but no one else does, and for good reason. Regular readers will already be aware that I have been against the idea of an .XXX from the start – as I was also against .mobi, .Tel, and a host of other pointless additional domain spaces. They are not needed. Their sole purpose is the generate money in registry fees. I firmly believe that granting of approval to the domain on 1 June 2005 was a mistake. So I am glad it hasn’t been green lighted … but for the life of me – looking at the documents submitted by the ICM Registry; the exemplary conduct by its head Stuart Lawley, in making every change asked of it in its registry agreement; and also examining the decisions in the cases of other sTLDs such as .mobi – I can see no reason why the board has not rubber stamped the sTLDs creation.
The proposal has sparked global debate, with a number of US family and child protection groups attacking the proposal. It has also raised more questions about the role of the US Government in running the internet as even if ICANN had approved the proposal, the US Commerce Department could still have blocked it. And this decision is all about the US Government and other Government’s belatedly (as public opinion changed) complaining about a domain for which they were originally in favour.
For me a case of the right result, but for all the wrong reasons. I look forward to reading a fuller description of the rational behind the decision and the comments of one of the domain’s supporters in the vote Susan Crawford.