Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Yahoo! Nazi memorabilia case thrown out

Yahoo! Nazi memorabilia case thrown out

13th January 2006 by Scott

A 6-5 split federal appeals court dismissed a lawsuit Thursday in which Yahoo! claimed its free speech rights were violated when a French court fined the company for displaying Nazi memorabilia for sale on its websites.

In 2000 France’s UEJF and the LICRA sued Yahoo! and won a French court “interim” order on 22 May requiring Yahoo! to “take all necessary measures to dissuade and render impossible any access [from French territory] via Yahoo.com In a second interim order issued on 20 November 2000, the French court reaffirmed its 22 May order and directed Yahoo! to comply within three months, “subject to a penalty of 100,000 Francs per day of delay effective from the first day following expiry of the 3 month period.” The French court has not imposed any penalty on Yahoo! for violations of the 22 May or 20 November orders. Nor has either LICRA or UEJF returned to the French court to seek the imposition of a penalty. Yahoo! maintains its current level of compliance. Yet neither organization is willing to ask the French court to vacate its orders.

In 2002 Yahoo! filed a lawsuit in San Jose, California, asking the U.S. District Court to rule that the French orders were not recognisable or enforceable in the US. LICRA and UEJF filed a motion to dismiss, and the Yahoo! filed a motion for summary judgment claiming the orders were invalid because they violated the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment.

The district court concluded that the suit was ripe, that abstention was not warranted, and that “the First Amendment precludes enforcement within the United States.”

The case was then heard by a 3 panel sitting of the 9th Circuit court who issued a decision in 2004 which in a 2-1 decision, emphasised that the French groups had not sued Yahoo in U.S. courts, and that jurisdiction, and first amendment claims could only be heard once LIVRA and UEJF asked the US district court to enforce the French orders, which up to this point they have not done. He stated: ” Yahoo! obtains commercial advantage from the fact that users located in France are able to access its website; in fact, the company displays advertising banners in French to those users whom it identifies as French. Yahoo! cannot expect both to benefit from the fact that its content may be viewed around the world and to be shielded from the resulting costs — one of which is that, if Yahoo! violates the speech laws of another nation, it must wait for the foreign litigants to come to the United States to enforce the judgment before its First Amendment claim may be heard by a U.S. court”.

The Full sitting of the court has now found that the judgment of the district court should be reversed and the case remanded with directions to dismiss the action without prejudice. The Court was divided in its opinions and reasoning with 8 of the 11 judges concluded that the district court had personal jurisdiction over the defendants, 3 that it didn’t; 3 concluded that the action should be dismissed for lack of ripeness, and 5 that the case was ripe for adjudication.

Judge William Fletcher wrote “Yahoo has chosen not to ask the French court whether unrelated changes in its policies have indirectly satisfied the foreign order … Instead, it has chosen to come home to ask for a declaratory judgment that the French court’s orders whatever they may or may not require, and whatever First Amendment questions they may or may not present are unenforceable in the United States.”

The legal question presented by this case is whether the two interim orders of the French court are enforceable the US. The Court found it would be difficult to know whether enforcement of the French court’s interim orders would be repugnant to California public policy, as the French orders were only ‘interim’ and could therefore be changed and modified, and also there was little evidence that French court will not insist on full and literal compliance with its interim orders, and that Yahoo!’s changed policy may amount to sufficient compliance. “Without a finding that further compliance with the French court’s orders would necessarily result in restrictions on access by users in the United States, the only question in this case is whether California public policy and the First Amendment require unrestricted access by Internet users in France.”

As such the majority of the Court were unsure there was a first amendment question to answer as things stood in the case. If the French court decided that Yahoo!’s current policy brought it into compliance with the interim measures ‘in large measure’ there is no first amendment question, and if the French court were to require additional compliance with respect to users in France, but that additional compliance would not require any restriction on access by users in the United States, Yahoo! would only be asserting a right to extraterritorial application of the First Amendment. As a result the court decided not to address that issue because a majority felt there was no First Amendment controversy to decide. “Precisely because of the novelty, importance and difficulty of the First Amendment issues Yahoo seeks to litigate, we should scrupulously observe the prudential limitations on the exercise of our power,” the court wrote

The Court also dismissed Yahoo!’s argument that it faced severe hardship because the financial penalty against it is mounting every day, that the enforcement of a penalty against it in the US would be extremely onerous, and that the order limits free speech. The court said not only were LICRA and UEJF on record as saying they had no intention of returning to the French court to enforce the orders – unless Yahoo! totally reversed its current policies, but even if it did it is exceedingly unlikely that any court in California (or indeed elsewhere in the United States) would enforce it. In addition it said that Yahoo!’s argument over free speech seemed to suggest that it felt it should have a First Amendment right to violate French criminal law and to facilitate the violation of French criminal law by others. Whilst the court did not dismiss this was extraterritorial right could exist, it said the the extent would be uncertain.

The majority felt it is a close question whether LICRA and UEJF are subject to personal jurisdiction in California in this suit, but felt on balance they were. The three judges who disagreed stated “The Supreme Court has never approved such a radical extension of personal jurisdiction,” adding that the majority had essentially held that a foreign party subjects itself to a suit in the U.S. simply “by litigating a bona fide claim in a foreign court and receiving a favorable judgment.”

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in