“[J]ust one single man and one single woman, subject to rigorous authentication and in reasonable health, and it could all begin again”
The Booker Prize, as all good prizes should do, has exasperated me at times over the years. In 2010 they decided that Howard Jacobson’s The Finkler Question was the best book out of the original 13 long-listed books. It was a book that would not have made my short-list and one that annoyed me intensely. I disliked the main characters, I found the forced comedy humourless, it left me cold. I had enjoyed The Mighty Waltzer and a couple of his other earlier books, so it wasn’t personal. Still, given that, the thought of a new Jacobson book after Finkler did not fill me great hope.
J is a dystopian love story about two loners, set in a future Britain, where, to paraphrase L.P. Hartley ‘The past is a (dangerous) foreign country: they do things differently there’. This a past that those in power are determined to keep there, a time before an unspeakable event or ‘What Happened, If It Happened’ as it is referred to throughout the book. This is a world in which there is a regulator of the people, Ofnow, tasked with monitoring the public mood. This is a sterile society bereft of challenging art and music – the radio plays endless love ballads – good news for fans of Steve Wright (UK DJ as opposed to US Comedian). A collective amnesia of WHIIH means everyone is meant to think of themselves as one big happy family now – the names have been changed to lurs the lines between the dead and the guilty.
The central characters, around whom the rest revolve, are Kevern Cohen and Ailinn Solomons. They are a couple who are thrown together by an immediately disappearing match-maker in a time where history books are hard to come by, diaries hidden or destroyed and that libraries put gentle obstacles in the way of research. They are an awkward couple. He is a wood turner who makes love spoons for the local village shop. He hears his mother’s voice calling to him, hoards his father’s old possessions – something not allowed in this new world, and suffers from OCD. She, in turn, is an orphan raised by nuns in a convent.
This is a book which reveals its secrets slowly, mainly through its supporting characters – Densdell Kroplik, a barber and local history expert; Detective Gutkind – a man who sees conspiracy everywhere; Edward Everett Phineas Zermansky an art teacher who is observing and writing a report on Kevern; Esme, who befriends Ailinn and offers her a home, and through various letters from the past.
The secrets and much of this ‘history’ is not that hard to guess. The place they live is called Port Reuben, the characters all have Jewish sounding surnames, the letter J is verboten. Perhaps less obvious initially is just why Kevern and Ailinn are our central characters.But that too becomes clear.
J is a compelling read, and represents Jacobson’s best work to date. Seemingly released from the need to try and be funny and to try and force humour into his text he has instead crafted an engaging tale of fear, hate, love and identity. “Identity is nothing but illusion …Only when we have a different state to strive against do we have reason to strive at all. And different people the same. I am me because I am not her, or you. … This is akin to something my own father is keen to stress when people are ultra patriotic – where you are born is an accident of birth, you had no choice or say in the matter. It’s also a novel about the importance of hate to our society, or at least in the sense that it creates discussion and argument, and what happens when that is lost. The answer is not very nice.
J is certainly one of the books of the year and I would be more than happy to see it win the prize.
[…] stuff. I’ve not yet gotten around to the winner but I thought Howard Jacobsen – J [my review] was certainly amongst the best he’d written, if not the best. Part dystopian love story, […]