Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / ICSTIS finds joke sms no joking matter

ICSTIS finds joke sms no joking matter

2nd August 2006 by Scott

It’s hard to read today’s ICSTIS adjudications against reverse billed SMS for jokes services without smiling. The decision are against 5 separate content providers … but reading them there does seem to something familiar about them all in that alls refer to “complainants had ‘opted-in’ to a weekly joke club upon dialling an 0871 number” and that this opt-in was “substantially earlier than the date at which they actually received chargeable messages”

How substantially earlier in each case?

Atlas Interactive Group Ltd, Hybyte Solutions and Services Ltd, Telecom One Ltd, Wireless Information Network Ltd (content and promotion were provided by Visual Success Ltd), and Zamano Ltd

“the Secretariat obtained call traffic records in respect of those who had completed an opt-in request, but failed to receive the actual content requested for up to 13 months”. (Telecom One Ltd)

“the Secretariat obtained call traffic logs in respect of those who had completed an opt-in request, but failed to receive the actual content requested for up to 13 months”. (Wireless Information Network Ltd)

“a call traffic record indicated that a complainant had failed to receive the actual content requested for up to approx 13 months”. (Zamano)

“the Secretariat obtained call traffic records in respect of those who had completed an opt-in request, but had not received any communication from the service, whether a confirmation message or the actual content requested for up to approx 12 months” ( Hybyte Solutions and Services)

“call traffic records indicated that those who dialled the 0871 number and completed an opt-in request, had failed to receive the actual content requested for up to approx 13 months” (Atlas Interactive Group).

So, no connection between any of these services then …

Zamano and Atlas Interactive have both requested reviews of the desions against them and both raised what should be an interesting point over the period at which a valid ‘opt-in’ becomes invalid. They point to the fact the the Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 do not specifically address this point and neither does the ICSTIS code. Both also cited the Information Commissioner’s guidance on the regulations (version 3, May 2004) in which ‘the information commissioner, at page 6 answers the question does the phrase for the time being mean consent only lasts a finite period of time as follows: ‘We do not interpret the phrase for the time being as meaning that consent must inevitably lapse after a certain period. Consent once given, will not inevitably last indefinitely. However it will remain valid until there is good reason to consider it no longer valid, or example, where it has been specifically withdrawn or it is otherwise clear that the recipient no longer wishes to receive such messages.’

One to watch.

The fun didn’t stop there though: there were two decisions relating to adult services. Dialler.com/Opera Telecom: Here Dialler.com’ defence against a claim by ICSTIS that “Pricing information did not appear to be mentioned in all of the promotional material. Furthermore, one of the pieces of the website promotional material appeared to state that calls to the service were 25p per minute, whereas the actual cost of calling the service was £1.50 per minute” was to argue that “the promotional material (websites) had been subjected to tampering” Nice try.

Meanwhile the Netcollex/ Opera Telecom adjudication saw Netcollex try and fail to put up a good defence for the use of the word ‘pussy’ in their promotional message which ICSTIS decide was foul language.

First off, Netcollex Ltd revealed that they had stopped using the word ‘pussy’ in their promotions during the investigation, but stated that in their opinion the word ‘pussy’ is not foul language and supplied three examples in support of this claim.

“Broadcast watershed – They stated that the word ‘pussy’, as a double entendre between ‘pussy-cat’ and ‘vagina’ was extensively used by Ms Slocombe in ‘Are you being served’ a sitcom which has been viewed by millions of families over the past 20 years.

Public opinion – Netcollex Ltd asked their female staff to write down every word they could think of for the female vagina. The word ‘pussy’ was considered the second least offensive with eighteen other words/phrases considered more offensive.

Interpretation of foul language – They stated that as a mobile phone is a non-shared medium, the recipient is the only person likely to view the content and therefore, these texts must be interpreted differently to a magazine or a newspaper”.

I have to confess I am with Netcollex on this one.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Anonymous says

    8th August 2006 at 2:19 pm

    Telecom One and their business partners Premium Media Communications and Sun Telecom were also involved in 20% of all internet rogue dialler complaints to Icstis in 2004 according to the BBC The Money Programme. The Great Phone Call Con 11/11/05.Icstis claimed Telecom One’s service providers had been under investigation from 1st Jan 04 onwards. They were using 3000 Telecom One numbers and Icstis recieved tens of thousands of complaints. According to Alun Michael they recieved their last complaint in May 05.An MP has just written to Margaret Hodge to ask why considering the level and nature of complaint BT were allowed to continue billing the services for seventeen months.A director of Premium Media and Sun Telecom was Morten Sondegaard Pedersen. He was a director of Telecom One in 1998. He was convicted of a massive telecom fraud in Germany in 2006.Another director of Premium Media and his South American business partner who is named in Spanish Companies House as being behind four “service providers” are also behind on-line gambling companies that the government is trying to attract “on shore”.God protect us cause Icstis aint.

  2. Scott says

    8th August 2006 at 3:10 pm

    ICSTIS sadly do not have much statutory power and need to rely on Ofcom in most cases – although they are starting to get more power and increased fining ability at least, which is a start. As you may be aware, ICSTIS issued directions to Telecom One under the ICSTIS Code of Practice and breaches Ofcom`s conditions on premium rate services in respect of four service providers in January and February 2005. ICSTIS then complained to Ofcom regarding allegations that they had failed to comply with directions. Ofcom dismissed the complaint finding that whilst Telecom One did provide late responses to the directions issued by ICSTIS, it had nonetheless since complied. It also found that the premium rate services that were being operated on Telecom One`s network had ceased. In addition, Ofcom found no evidence of any material consumer detriment as a result of Telecom One`s delay in responding to the directions. However, Telecom One was not left completely in the clear as Ofcom warned that it must comply with its duty to act in accordance with directions issued by ICSTIS under its Code of Practice.[ see http://www.ofcom.org.uk/ bulletins/ comp_bull_index/ comp_bull_ccases/ closed_all/ cw_833/ ]In addition in March this year Telecom One was fined £10,000, issued with a formal reprimand and ordered to offer full refunds to all complainants, relating to a promotion by http://www.ef1.biz of a premium rate website by reverse-billed text message, which failed to contain an unsubscribe option. [see http://www.icstis.org.uk/consumers/adjudications/default.asp?node=&id=447 ]

  3. Anonymous says

    8th August 2006 at 7:58 pm

    Telecom One is and was involved in serious criminal activity. It should be a matter for the police not an industry sponsored regulator.In fact there may be a case to ask what part Icstis’ “investigation” played in the success of the dialler fraud. If the Icstis fines and reprimands worked why do the same people keep coming back?ef1.bizIf you have any further queries,you may contact us on the following address:Attention: Redisham Ltd “F1 Service”C.C. Cristamar, Local 11, mailbox 72Puerto Banus, 29660, Marbella, SpainIberian HoldingsCITIBOX Puerto Banús.Local 11, Centro Comercial Cristamar.P.O.Box nº7229660 Marbella, SpainWhy did Icstis “beg” Rubert Jones the Guardian journalist not to identify the Majorcan companies on 3rd July 04. They told him they did not want their investigation jeopardised.This reason was of course rubbish, they had been identified on the Icstis web site as being under investigation from 1st Jan 04 onwards. Icstis had been advising members of the public by the thousand to write to these companies.In July 2004 Icstis claimed they were co-operating closely with the police High Tech Crime Unit. How close?Did they tell them that:Quizir slMesa RotationAmara AmichiCala de Plata slwere using 2,400 Telecom One premium 0909967**** numbers and were responsible for thousands of complaints each month?Did Icstis’ seventeen month “investigation” discover all four Telecom One “service providers” were infact registered at the same Spanish address:c/Puigdorfila2,1B,07001Palmaby the same Uraguayan business man.A business partner to Telecom One?

  4. Scott says

    8th August 2006 at 10:46 pm

    If you want to know details of the icstis investigation, put in a freedom of information request for the information to icstis.

  5. Anonymous says

    11th August 2006 at 10:23 pm

    Original Icstis Download showing Quizir SL under investigation 01/01/2004 onwardshttp://img125.imageshack.us/img125/9208/icstisquizirpic2zk6.jpgPremium Media Communications 01/01/2004 onwardshttp://img304.imageshack.us/img304/1394/icinvestcolour1final2cy.jpg………………………..http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200506/cmhansrd/cm051219/text/51219w12.htmSaturday July 3, 2004The Guardian Rupert Jones“I then went to Icstis. I gave them the two 09099 numbers on my bill and they revealed there had been 25 or more complaints about each since the end of May. They were able to disclose the name and address of the people behind one of the numbers – a company based in a European holiday hotspot.Much as I would like to name and shame these scumbags, Icstis begged me to keep schtum because it is still investigating. Identifying the company could jeopardise the chances of nabbing them. I wasn’t impressed to learn that my tormentors lease their line from a leading UK telecommunications firm.”………………………….Icstis said each 09099 number had recieved 25 or more complaints since the end of May.Premium Media Communications ran 30009099673654 to 09099673953Quizir sl ran 90009099676060 to 0909967645909099677100 to 09099677599 Mesa Rotation ran 50009099678600 to 09099679099Amara Amichi ran 50009099679100 to 0909967929909099679608 to 09099679907Cala de Plata sl ran 500Icstis recieved at least 2700*25=67,500 complaints for this group of five companies.22,500 for Quizir aloan!What did Icstis say?http://news.zdnet.co.uk/internet/security/0,39020375,39158412,00.htmZDNet UKJune 23, 2004“If it’s only a few cases, then we can put it down to the husband or kids not admitting to surfing porn, but if 300 customers are saying the same thing about one company, then we can’t ignore it,” said Baht. “We can’t work out what the problem is, so have recently started talking to the Hi-Tech Crime Unit so they can do a criminal investigation.”Background information from the media. http://www.pieman.sonnexh.com/Backgroundinformationfromthemedia.doc

  6. Anonymous says

    11th November 2006 at 10:08 pm

    “If you want to know details of the icstis investigation, put in a freedom of information request for the information to icstis.”Thanks Scott.[ see http://www.ofcom.org.uk/ bulletins/ comp_bull_index/ comp_bull_ccases/ closed_all/ cw_833/ ]Ofcom cited the act to avoid naming the service providers. Grazy or what?A member of parliament asked Sir Alistair Graham (Icstis) directly.Now I know why Ofcom tried to hide who they were.The fourth referral in the case concerns seven Majorcan “service providers” that were involved in the BBC programme “The Great Phone Call Con”.Throughout 2004 icstis were claiming the services appeared to be compliant. So BT were claiming there was no legal reason not to pay the bills.It now appears Icstis had no evidence or reason to believe the services were being legally promoted or even existed.Considering the tens of thousands of identical complaints about these seven service providers Icstis must have known the bills were the result of fraud. Ofcom must have known.Complicity and duplicity.

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in