Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Jamba take on the ASA, but ASA wins first round

Jamba take on the ASA, but ASA wins first round

22nd September 2005 by Scott

I see the UK Court turned down a request by Jamba for an injunction to prevent the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) from publishing its decision to uphold complaints from almost 300 people against adverts for Jamba for a collection of ads for reverse billed ringtones featuring Crazy Frog, Nessie the Dragon and Sweetie the Chick. Jamba wanted the publication postponed until its request for an independent review was decided.

Mr. Justice Lloyd-Jones however sided with the ASA and accepted the argument that the public interest was best served by publishing the adjudication now, notwithstanding Jamba’s request for an independent review.

The ASA upheld complaints that the ads did not make it clear enough that a subscription service was being offered, and that the ads were of particular appeal to children so should only be broadcast after the 9pm watershed. The ASA dismissed argument by Jamster that they had amended their ads following a previous decision by the ASA (see Development Date; 6 April 2005) finding that (i) whilst it agreed that they would need to ‘join’ the Jamster Club, they would not necessarily understand that join meant subscribe, since not all clubs charge a fee or subscription; (ii) that the use of plurals ‘text xxx for polys’ had not clarified a continuing commitment, and that (iii) the amended ads still did not state the recurring cost prominently. The ASA also found evidence offered by Jamster to show their customers were adults and not children was inadequate as it was based on calls to their customer service department received over a 6 day period. Whilst the ASA agreed that the ads were not aimed at children they found it most unlikely that a child would not have been aware of the characters, considering that there were 40,000 broadcasts of the ads in a one-month period. The frequency of the ads, peer pressure, a hit single, and the use of cartoon characters combined with a product that is of interest to children, combined with the ease with which is was possible to subscribe to the ringtones, all, in the view of the ASA, added to the problem. If broadcast again the ads will have to be braodcast after 9pm.

Jamster will now pin its hopes on the independent review. However the independent reviewer has first to decide whether to accept Jamba’s request for review. If he does he can return the adjudication to the ASA Council for further consideration. Jamba has said it finds the decision against it flawed, unjust and unfounded.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Anonymous says

    22nd September 2005 at 5:16 pm

    You’ve made a terrific blog. If you have a web site, I’m sure you’d like< HREF="http://www.viralnews.com" REL="nofollow"> FREE eBooks<> Get your FREE eBooks

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in