Law of the Jungle
Paul M Barrett
Website: www.AuthorPMBarrett.com
Published 23 September 2014 [US Only: No UK publication date at time of writing]
“What gets my metabolism racing … is the idea that the law can be used as a weapon to club injustice into submission and create a better world” – Stephen Donziger
Bloomberg Journalist Paul Barrett’s latest book has its origins in a profile he did of New York lawyer Steven Donziger for Business week. It details a twenty year legal battle over environmental pollution in the Ecuadorian Amazon which resulted, in 2011, in one of the largest ever judgements imposed by a court for such pollution – $18.2 Billion (although as we learn in the book the question as to whether or not that judgement will ever be enforced is uncertain, leaning towards unlikely). It’s immediately engaging, gripping and, in the end, a fascinating look at human nature and the desire to win.
The book opens with the following paragraph:
“The lawyer Stephen Donziger stepped out into 104th Street. He looked west towards Riverside park and east towards Broadway. The dark sedans had been tailing him for at least a month now. They followed him for blocks at a time, slowing when he slowed, stopping when he stopped, their passengers watching his every move.”
Immediately you are imagining Tom Cruise in some John Grisham thriller, well until you learn Donzinger is six foot four and then perhaps you’re thinking Liam Neeson or Bradley Cooper instead (not, of course, that height issues stopped Tom Cruise playing Jack Reacher). We have our hero. He is going to take on the big nasty corporate oil giant in a David v Goliath battle and emerge worthy and victorious. Hell, the book’s sub title is ‘ The $19 Billion Legal Battle Over Oil in the Rain Forest and the Lawyer Who’d Stop at Nothing to Win’ . He’s the hero, and he’s going to win, right?
For the first couple of chapters you’re holding on to that thought but then we begin to see that all are not roses in this legal garden and maybe things might not be quite as black and white as we thought. As Barrett himself states, what follows is as tale with no shortage of knaves and villains.
Filed in 1993 on behalf of a group of Ecuadorian Indians of the Oriente region, the Aguinda lawsuits against Texaco, who were later acquired by Chevron, sought the clean-up of a region of jungle that had been left with serious water and ground pollution as a result of years of Texaco’s oil drilling. Donziger, a young man with no civil litigation experience, soon becomes lead council and driving force behind the case. He’s a larger than life protagonist. He has a principle belief of writing the wrongs of the world, and of the law as the leveller to deliver justice. He also has a flare for attention and promotion, and an understanding that media and perception are as important as hard facts in raising awareness of a cause. He is the consummate showman, as the opportunity to appear in a documentary about the case (Joe Berlinger’s 2009 film ‘Crude‘) proves. Little did he know it may also prove his undoing.
In Barrett’s hands this book is a real page turner. We get sucked in to the world where winning, and winning at all costs, is the only thing that matters for either side. We get a picture of a man who becomes consumed by this seemingly never ending case, and is so sure that the other side will use any means to secure victory that he pre-empts their actions with questionable ones of his own – deceit, blackmail, bribery, fraud, raging egotism and double and treble crossing: it’s all here.
For Donziger, this was his only real case as a lawyer. Lose and he’d wasted twenty years of his life and he would have little to show for it. Win, and he’d be a legal giant able to write his own cheques for any future work. If that meant putting pressure on foreign judges or actively trying to prevent the very thing you claim to be in court arguing for – the clean-up of polluted land – so be it.
But this far from a one man story. Yes, the focus is on Donzinger, but no one comes out of this case smelling of roses. Donzinger, Chevron and its legal team, and the various Ecuadorian governments all shoulder the blame for a runaway case that could and should have settled many years ago, but didn’t because ego’s, and winning on both sides became all that mattered.
It’s a case packed with hypocrisy, with both sides flip-flopping on whether US or Ecuadorian courts were the only venue that could provide justice. But, what is justice?
In the end, you feel for the people that this case was supposed to be about. The people meant to be at the heart of the story who in the end were left high and dry by their lawyers – despite ‘winning’ – and who were also hung out to dry by big oil and their own government, who had, after all, invited Texaco in and took 90% of the oil money – and who own Petroecuador who now run the Texaco oil wells. You could even make the same assertion about Barrett himself, as the Ecuadorians take a back seat to Donzinger. The whole situation is best summed up in the book by Sting: “This is all a sideshow … A lot of lawyers arguing … while people are still suffering in the rain forest.”
It would also have been nice to have had more firsthand independent reporting (Donzinger, perhaps unsurprisingly, declined to be interviewed for the book) and less seeming reliance on court record, existing materials and Joe Berlinger’s film – which this book made me re-watch. None of this, however, takes away from it being a good read.
In the end you put the book down thinking that Crude might not be the last time we the see Stephen Donzinger and the Aguinda case on the big screen.
The pages are surely packed with hypocrisy. In fact, the entire thing is a “page turner” because that’s exactly how Chevron has told the story. Which Barrett simply re-tells. With no real analysis, reporting or impartiality.
The book is a pro-Chevron farce, as another reviewer put it, one more clearly more aware with the actual details and truth behind Chevron’s deliberate dumping of billions of gallons of toxic waste, and their stated strategy of vilifying their victims and lawyers rather than address the actual claims agains them.
“There are two sides to the story of the biggest environmental lawsuit ever, but a new book tells only one of them.” Read it here: http://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/media/books/A-Jungle-Eco-Battle-for-Your-Reading-List.html?271734551&utm_content=buffera480d&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Nice try Barrett. Now tell us all how BP shouldn’t pay up for the gulf spill either.
Thanks for the comment. I presume you’ve read the book?
I am aware of criticisms of the book but I can only review books from my perspective not another reviewers perspectives – sorry. Also I don’t spend several months researching subjects of books, otherwise I’d not read very many and I’d be writing them, not reviewing them.
In this case all I can say from my perspective is that I didn’t finish the book thinking Texaco/Chevron were not guilty and shouldn’t pay up, so clearly Barrett didn’t do a very good job of writing a pro-chevron ‘farce’.
Hi, yes. Here’s the point – it’s exactly what Chevron wanted Barrett to write. As you can clearly see, there’s no defending themselves on the merits of the case. Chevron’s stated strategy was to invalidate the ruling against them. Their effort to do that led to this bogus RICO action. It’s based on false and manipulated evidence, here say statements from corrupt witnesses PAID to testify and pressure tactics by Chevron and their lawyers against witnesses.
Barrett provides a misleading and journalistically unethical presentation ignoring major points against Chevron. This is either by design or lack of ability to do actual investigative reporting.
Here’s just a few MAJOR flaws:
**The book has no footnotes, borrows from the work of others without proper citation, and is replete with factual errors;
**Barrett ignores scientific reports that clearly demonstrate Chevron discharged billions of gallons of toxic waste into the Amazon, causing an ecological
calamity;
**Barrett ignores documented evidence that Chevron defrauded Ecuador courts by switching out dirty soil samples for clean ones, undercounting
hydrocarbons, and hiding evidence of its contamination;
**Law of the Jungle was dated before it even came out given that the legal case is still being contested in the courts of five countries;
**Barrett, who does not speak Spanish and spent no more than a few days in Ecuador, wholly ignores the critical leadership role of internationally-recognized
Ecuadorian advocates Pablo Fajardo and Luis Yanza.
**Barrett’s conclusions are skewed by his personal, unprofessional animus toward Steven Donziger, the U.S. legal advisor to the Ecuadorians.
(http://chevrontoxico.com/assets/docs/2014-barrett-critique.pdf)
The most interesting thing about his book is how it plays to completely into the oil giants strategy. The REAL story is how an oil company so obviously guilty of a MASSIVE, deliberate environmental and human rights crime can use unlimited funds and pressure to avoid accountability for decades.
Yep I’d read the Lago Agrio legal team piece – as well as other reviews etc after done mine. Still doesn’t change my review of ‘the book’. Others (yourself included of course) are welcome to write their own reviews, based on their own views and knowledge etc. I can only write my own based on the case I was aware from the original documentary and of the reading the book.
Of course you can write your own. The problem I have with it is Barrett furthering of Chevron’s complete falsehoods and lies about the case are taken at face value:
“winning at all costs, is the only thing that matters for either side. We get a picture of a man who becomes consumed by this seemingly never ending case, and is so sure that the other side will use any means to secure victory that he pre-empts their actions with questionable ones of his own – deceit, blackmail, bribery, fraud, raging egotism and double and treble crossing: it’s all here.”
Winning at all costs is in fact NOT the only thing that matters. And I know this as a fact as someone who has worked to help the Ecuadorians for the better part of a decade. The “blackmail, bribery, fraud,” etc. are ALL based on the testimony of an admitted liar and corrupt ex-judge. This case will likely be completely overturned on appeal. The whole point of the case was to get a talking point for Chevron to tout outside the US since they have no legal remedy in the US anyway. Chevron has never been concerned with the truth of what happened in this case, and neither was Barrett. Their legal tactics have repeatedly violated the rights of US citizens and over 250,000 people have already sent messages to the US Senate calling for an investigation into Chevron’s shady tactics. Where does Barrett cover the depths of deceit and pressure tactics employed by Chevron and Gibson Dunn?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3nPxc31Qt4
It’s an absurdly one-sided look at the case and with all due respect any responsible review of the book should concede that fact.
‘With all due respect’ …ah, don’t you just love that phrase. At the risk of beginning to sound like a broken record – and so this will be my final comment on this post, as circular argument comment threads always seem rather redundant…and I have a book on adoption I need to review …
A responsible review. A ‘responsible’ review is one that its true to its author and reflects what they read and thought about the thing they have read and not what someone else thinks they should have thought. Sorry if you have a problem with that. You comment that Barrett’s book is exactly what Chevron ‘wanted him to write’, whilst at the same time seeming to criticise my review because I haven’t written the one you wanted me to write. It seems to imply I should have written it with your knowledge not my own, or periodically re-write my review as new contrary opinion comes to light.
As I said you or indeed anyone one else who wants to can review this book and say whatever they like about it. Or write there own book. Happy to read it. My responsibility as a reader, and as someone who occasionally reviews the books I read for PLEASURE – this is not my job or profession (in case you haven’t noticed my blog is not attached to the New York Times, or London Times, or Huff Post, nor is this review posted on Amazon (no pun intended) where it would get a hell of a lot more ‘reads’) – is to provide my honest opinion of how I find the books that I read. Which is what I did in this case.
In doing so I stick with what I say towards the end of my review ‘It would also have been nice to have had more firsthand independent reporting and less seeming reliance on court record, existing materials and Joe Berlinger’s film – which this book made me re-watch. None of this, however, takes away from it being a good read.’ That’s what I thought. It may be a one sided account – frankly I can count on one hand the amount of books of this type that I have read that are even vaguely neutral or balanced, and I may have my own personal views on the actual case as a whole, but none of that takes away from the fact I found it a good read. Sorry.
You think differently. Great. That’s why I’m more than happy to have your comments attached to this post.
Now that reading the book and re-watching Crude has re-awakened an interest in the case I will not doubt comment on any future developments in the case(s) here too.
Excellent… stay tuned for the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals to overturn the Kaplan verdict. I will send you a photo of Barrett with egg on his face to go with along with the post. 🙂
OOPS! http://www.csrwire.com/press_releases/37364-Random-House-and-BusinessWeek-s-Paul-Barrett-Receive-Defamation-Notice-Over-Chevron-Pollution-Case