Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Books / The joy of the Unofficial Guide to Adoptive Parenting

The joy of the Unofficial Guide to Adoptive Parenting

1st October 2014 by Scott

This is a review but it also may become a ramble, for that I apologise right up front. When you’ve recently adopted as we have anything that comes along that ‘speaks to you’ directly, as Sally Donovan’s book does can’t just be dealt with in a simple, yes she talks about X, Y and Z and it was all very nice.

The Unofficial Guide to Adoptive Parenting
Sally Donovan
Jessica Kingsley Publishers
UK Pub Date Nov 21 2014

‘I’ve come to learn that my values are different from my dreams. My values are hard and have meaning whereas my dreams are flimsy vanity projects like my pretend mini-me children’

I don’t know. You wait for ages for a really great adoption book to come along and then like buses, two come along at once. I wrote the other week about Julia Davis’ upcoming book, Preparing for Adoption, and now, from the same publisher – Jessica Kingsley Publishers – comes Sally Donovan’s – The Unofficial Guide to adoptive Parenting. Whilst Julia is a Child and Family Therapist, Sally is an adoptive parent and writer (whose previous book No Matter What also dealt with her personal experience of adoption).

This one is less of a memoir than No Matter What and more an attempt to provide some practical guidance and strategies for adopters on how to deal with their children, as well as other people and professionals that they will encounter, based on her personal experience as an adoptive parent.

‘What’s shareable is bearable’

Is it good?

I usually tend to make a point of not swearing in reviews, but it somehow it seems appropriate for this down to earth book. In short, I fucking loved it.

Whilst it is always great to read books by experts in the field of childcare and therapy – again, see my recent review of Julia Davis’ Preparing for Adoption – it is also nice to hear from people who actual KNOW what you’re going through or may go through in reality. This is why, for most people, the most effective bits of their adoption process are those times at preparation groups when other adopters come along and speak of their experiences of adoption and allow you to ask questions about what it is REALLY like, not what someone’s book or a social worker tells you it will be like: the non sugar-coated story.

And, that, is what you get here. Donovan takes us through, basic routines, copping with weekends , holidays and ‘event days’, regression, meltdowns, sibling rivalry, school, life story work, self care and other things. At the heart of her approach is the idea of being a therapeutic parent – ‘we must spend most of our time in receive and learn mode’, and of making sure you seek out ‘helpful help’ as opposed to ‘unhelpful help’ offered by professionals. According to Donovan, ‘I’ve learned that unless a professional knows about trauma and attachment there is little point in getting involved with them’

I think this is a sound approach, as it is generally important that we don’t find a solution and then try and fit the problem to that solution. If someone is an ‘expert’ at something or someone is a convert to a particular method of parenting – and this could even apply to Donavan herself – there is a danger that you stop seeing past the method or thing that you’re an expert in and will always ‘fit’ the child and any behaviours of the child into that method/area, regardless of whether or not that is the appropriate place for them to be placed. We are, to be fair, all guilty of this in life – it is, I would say, human nature to do so. But, what reading books about adoption and looked after children in the last couple of years has highlighted to me more than anything else is the importance of remaining open to new things – methods, approaches etc: you need to be adaptable. Donovan has clearly remained open to new things and adding tools which work for her to her own adoption toolbox.

For me, I immediately identified with the world described by Donovan. In particular the fact that whenever you adopt you immediately encounter a lot of, mostly well meaning family and friends, who will say: ‘They wont remember’, ‘Children are so resilient, they’ll get over it’, ‘all children do that’, ‘all they need is firm boundaries’, ‘they’ll grow out of it’, the best approach is to ‘move on’ and ‘ why would you want to drag up the past?’. (I experienced this at a work event just last night, and the urge to just say ‘fuck right off’ was close to my lips on more than one occasion)

Being truthful it’s easy to let yourself get seduced by these kind of comments, after all, you want your child to be ‘normal’; you don’t want them to feel different form the other kids at school, for example, and you don’t want to be THAT parent that seems to be making ‘excuses’ for their child’s behaviour. It really is easy to fall into that way of thinking when surrounded by a constant stream of people making these type of comments. And yet, as Donovan says what these comments really are is ‘Hogwash’.

We are talking about children who have had serious trauma in their lives, and often a lack of strong attachment. If we talk of a child that has been neglected, it’s not insignificant: ‘Neglect isn’t just a dirty house and a bit of time spent alone … neglect is emotional and physical torture and impacts upon children profoundly.’ Hear, hear. We as adopters need to remind ourselves that just because all seems well on the outside doesn’t mean that suddenly everything is fine and it’ll all work itself out without any real effort on our part. I was reading the other day about some recent work looking at the brains of looked after children and soldiers coming back from Afghanistan. It has shown remarkable similarities with their brains with regards to the effects of trauma. It is a very real thing.

Other sections of the book which resonated with me personally were the bits about school and life book work.

Donovan has some great ideas about what to look for in a school, what questions to ask. We did many of them, but there were a few I’m now regretting we didn’t think of, in particular the issue of behaviour policy – sanctions or rewards? How public are these? . I must admit I’m guilty of not considering whether anything like this could result in my child being’ shamed’ and having a possible negative image of themselves reinforced. As Donovan says, systems which involve public shaming may just teach a child already acquainted with shame of their past life that they are indeed bad and it’s all their fault.

You get so caught up in your child’ excitement about going to school – a year of full time nursery in foster care meant she already saw it as something normal and something she enjoyed – which meant that whilst we did make sure that the school had experience of looked after children and in providing support for them, we totally overlooked something as, quite frankly, obvious as this.

But it also highlighted something I’d done myself. I’m ashamed to say in just three months I have said shaming things to my daughter on more than one occasion. The first time I did it I didn’t even realise I was doing it, the next time I did and immediately apologised and hugged my daughter to tell her that daddy sometimes said things that were not nice. Was this how I was parented? I can’t truthfully remember, but the negativity is not nice. I’d like to think I won’t do it again. . I was reminded of something my mom once said to me which was if you haven’t got anything nice to say about something don’t say anything at all. I don’t actually totally agree with this statement, but the idea behind it, one of being positive rather than negative is something that I think we as parents should aspire to.

Elsewhere, the chapter on Life Story Work(LSW) is just marvelous. Some may find a seeming dichotomy in this chapter between on the one hand seeming to advocate avoiding LSW and on the other getting annoyed with people telling you not to drag up the past. But it’s not avoidance that is being recommended over LSW here but rather not being guilt tripped into thinking it has to be done at a proscribed pace and at set, planned times. I totally agree with Donavan here, no child is the same and these things should be handled organically: we are not trying to forget things, we are allowing our child/children to lead us.

She also comments that much life story work done in car, and even in our 13 week experience, I think this is spot on. Here and perhaps just before lights out at bedtime our daughter will sometimes decide it is time to make a comment about her birth parents or siblings or just ask a question about her past, and/or her future. ‘Where will I go when you get bored of me’ is as heartbreaking a sentence as you will ever hear.

Even at this early stage in my own adoption journey (I’ve watch X-factor so I know the importance of being on a ‘journey’) reading this book was a great way of re-reminding myself of some of the things I should be either doing or considering doing. This is a warts and all book, and probably funnier for it (and it is often funny). Probably the best recommendation I can give this book is to say that I will be buying it in hard copy as soon as it comes out, as some books deserve a place on an actual shelf where you can get to them quickly when you need them. This is one such book. Not only that but will also pick up a couple of extra copies for family members too, to help with their understanding of the reality of our wonderful situation.

Filed Under: Books Tagged With: adoption

Trackbacks

  1. Information Overlord | What’s Shareable is bearable: New book on adoption and the importance of reading all you can says:
    21st November 2014 at 10:31 am

    […] has read and learned as much as possible to help herself be the best adoptive parent she can be [Read my review here] With that in mind I was thinking about adoption books and reading and concluded that the best […]

  2. Information Overlord | Books of 2014 says:
    8th December 2014 at 2:11 pm

    […] focused way. Then there was Sally Donavon’s Unofficial Guide to Adoptive Parenting [My review]. One of the stand out book of any kind this year. It is full of humour and real life examples of […]

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in