Information Overlord

Literature, Law, Librarianship and More

  • Adoption
  • Books
  • Law & Legal
  • Libraries & KM
  • Media & Broadcasting
  • Politics
  • Telecoms
You are here: Home / Media & Broadcasting / BBC / TV Licence needed for online and mobile TV?

TV Licence needed for online and mobile TV?

11th January 2008 by Scott

Tom Loosemore has an interesting post in which he asks if just owning a PC could mean that you need a TV Licence in the UK. He points to comments made by the BBC’s Director of BBC Future Media and Technology, Ashley Highfield, who states that whilst using the BBC’s iPlayer on demand Internet TV service would not need a licence, watching any live stream on BBC News 24, for example would.

As Tom points out this is an interesting question, the Communications (Television Licensing) Regulations 2004 (as amended ) section 11 reads:

(1) In Part 1 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1967, “television set” means any apparatus which (either alone or in association with other apparatus) is capable of receiving (whether by means of wireless telegraphy or otherwise) any television programme service but is not computer apparatus or a mobile telephone.

(2) In this regulation, “computer apparatus” means apparatus which –
(a) is designed or adapted to be used (either alone or in association with other apparatus) for storing or processing data, but not for doing so in connection with the reception by means of wireless telegraphy of television programme services; and

(b) is not offered for sale or letting as apparatus for use (either alone or in association with other apparatus) primarily for or in connection with the reception (whether by means of wireless telegraphy or otherwise) of such services;

Are modern day PC’s designed or adapted “in connection with the reception by means of wireless telegraphy of television programme services” ? Well , my current desk top machine came with an external digital TV card and many now come with internal TV cards, so I’d say the answer must be yes. BUT, if you don’t have a TV card and you’re just watching over your broadband connection? I think the wording of the regulation gives a bit more room to fudge the issue on this side of things, but at the end of the day I think there is an argument – that will only get louder over the next 18 months – that anyone with a computer/mobile phone capable of receiving the BBC live will leave its owner open to the charge of needing a TV licence to legally do so – if they don’t already have one/are covered by another one.

Filed Under: BBC, TV

Comments

  1. iOverlord says

    19th June 2013 at 8:53 am

    Moon23 Says:
    January 17th, 2008 at
    Furthermore if computers become the dominant medium for receiving BBC programs, will it still be called a TV license? Seeing as the BBC puts content on it’s website that is accessible for people without a TV license shouldn’t we now move towards having a computer license.
    Hilary Says:
    February 8th, 2008 at
    I think this just shows how far behind the times the BEEB can be, but a TV licence for a pc?
    I for one would think that a personal data device such as a pc as a licensing model would be a nightmare to police. I base this on t he difficulty in gaining access to property, after all where would it stop with mobile phones?
    Also mobile phones now being able to display tv and there are 70 million mobile phones in the UK and only 15 million pc’s. What next base the licence fee on the property or the mobile phone.
    Can you imagine base property agents trying to let a fully furnished flat with a PC? Not only that basically a TV license is only applicable if the user actually switches it on, how do you prove a negative?
    I base this on the fact that to do email you have to put the pc on and the property companies would then base their property costs on the size of the pc and the screen etc etc
    Base the license model on the Tv and noting else I say, if the Beeb wants to put content on the air for free like it does with You tube, why base the property or licence fe on anything else – we pay enough as it is and we are being treated like criminals. Why doesn’t the Beeb just stop sucking us dry and get real just like the other stations? Because the Govt wants us to cough up for social programming, in which case it should be paying for it instead of buying up defunct banks. Base the proposed licence on that instead. Makes just as much sense and taxing the PC’s.
    Peter Maxwell Says:
    March 6th, 2008 at
    After a series of ambiguous TVL responses designed to get one of their inspectors inside my house, i finally got this reply by e-mail. Perhaps useful clarification for people in my position.
    TV LICENSING
    BRISTOL
    BS98 1TL
    Tel: 0844 800 6702
    Fax: 0844 800 5816
    Email: tvlcsc@capita.co.uk
    Our Ref: TVL7393821
    Response received: 06/03/2008
    Thank you for contacting us.
    You will not need a TV licence.
    The use of television sets, video cassette recorders, set-top boxes or DVD recorders to receive or record television programme services must be covered by an appropriate TV Licence (A video cassette recorder, DVD recorder or colour television, whether used separately or together, will require a colour TV Licence, if used in this way). A licence is also required if a TV-enabled personal computer is used to record or receive television programmes.
    I hope this helps.
    Yours sincerely
    Cleo Hines
    TV Licensing
    Original Inquiry: 03/03/2008
    Subject: Other
    Message:
    Dear Representative of TVLA
    I have so far been unable to get a straight answer regarding two very
    specific (but straightforward) questions I have put to TVLA in the past.
    Please do not refer me to your frequently asked questions as these do NOT
    answer these questions. I would be much obliged if you would answer them
    here.
    1) Is a Television (that is in NO WAY capable of receiving
    telecommunications independently, nor connected to any aerial, cable or
    any other means of telecommunications reception) that is also connected to
    a DVD player (that is similarly incapable of receiving telecommunications
    independently nor is it connected in ANY WAY to any aerial, cable or any
    other means of telecommunications reception – NOR is able to RECORD in any
    way) in need of a TV license?
    If so, please refer me to the specific statutory provisions and/or
    relevant flagship case law upon which you base your determination.
    2) Is a personal computer that is connected to the internet via broadband,
    but is NEVER used to view or access ANY television programming (either
    Live or otherwise) nor is capable of receiving or connected for the
    purposes of receiving in any other way telecommunications, required to
    have a TV license?
    If so, please refer me to the specific statutory provisions and/or
    relevant flagship case law upon which you base your determination.
    Nick Reynolds (editor, BBC Internet Blog) Says:
    March 11th, 2008 at
    You may be interested in this post from Ashley Highfield on the BBC Internet Blog:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2008/01/iplayer_does_not_require_a_tv_1.html
    Ashley says:
    “At the moment, the legal position is that you don’t need a licence to watch TV purely on-demand, but you do if you are watching TV live (through any receiving device in the home)…
    … “a live simulcast over the web from the BBC – of, say, the Beijing Olympics – will require a TV licence, but watching an on-demand (non-live) stream or download through the BBC iPlayer will not.
    The Help section for the iPlayer confirms the position under “Will I need a TV licence to watch programmes on BBC iPlayer?” It states that:
    You do not need a television licence to watch television programmes on the current version of the BBC iPlayer. You will need to be covered by a TV licence if and when the BBC provides a feature that enables you to watch ‘live’ TV programmes on any later version of the BBC iPlayer which has this option… A ‘live’ TV programme is a programme which is watched or recorded at the same time (or virtually the same time) as it is being broadcast… “
    scott Says:
    March 11th, 2008 at
    Thanks for the comment Nick. As I said in original post it only really becomes an issue when you’re watching ‘live’ broadcasts.
    Neil Says:
    April 5th, 2008 at
    I think this issue, regarding watching TV that is not “live” being lawfull without any licence will change.
    Clearly there has been a shift in many households from sitting and glaring at the box, to searching and finding entertaining footage of personal interest at leisure.
    The government must be working on a broadband tax as we speak to tax this new found freedom, why not they even tax death in the form of inheritance tax? Not sure how they can Tax the guy who is not online, who is watching DVD’s on his laptop. Probably not possible, apart from the VAT on the DVD and the laptop.
    Was interesting to note recently that Tony Blair paid his TV Licence whilst in office at number 10, it was found in his expenses claim!
    Robert Macbeth Says:
    April 7th, 2008 at
    I own a computer and have the internet but I also build my own systems which gives me the freedom of not owning a TV.
    I have been exempt from having to buy a TV licence for years as the BBC have no legal right to see what I do on the internet.
    I have allowed them to see my desktop and rear of PC which shows no TV card or ariel connection and their representative tried talking down to me about how I could view TV on the internet if I wanted.
    I told him I could, but then you don’t own the internet, nor does the BBC, so don’t even go down that road.
    I also recently gained a degree in Multimedia Technology & Design at Brunel University which meant I spent some years on the law and legal requirements about Multimedia Broadcasting and the tactics and monopolizing that the BBC have done since the 50’s
    purpleline Says:
    July 15th, 2008 at
    I believe as we go on to improve live TV and online streaming capabilities, the licence fee should be dropped in favour of a general fee levied by BT who own the last mile >line into the property< with a no fee age limit for OAP’s and Hospitals nursing homes etc etc.
    ISP broadband providers should equally be charged extra fees and this should be passed on to broadband subscribers. This would move the subject forward reduce the bureaucratic requirement of collecting and monitoring TV licence fees & dodgers. It would also ensure the laws have caught up with technology.
    Finally, the fee should be reduced and the BBC should be reduced and privatised and allowed to advertise to ensure the licence fee levied in this way is lower.
    Brian Lockey Says:
    July 25th, 2008 at
    I have a TV capable of receiving terrestrial signals. However I live in a remote area and position within that area where there is no signal (honestly…not a sausage, not even a flashing, wobbly b&w hissy ghost of a picture, anywhere, on any band).
    Complaints to the BBC about the lack of reception have not been sympathetically dealt with. Their answer is, essentially, that iPlayer and satellite services are available for people like me. I don’t think it is morally correct that I should have to pay the licence fee for a terrestrial broadcasting service I cannot receive on my TV. Has anyone ever managed to get a refund in this situation?
    Actually, we have forked out more cash to install Sky & no doubt we must have a licence to cover the Sky box. However, my wife & I watch live TV so little these days we think we could get by without it altogether & just watch DVDs and streamed non-live stuff. If we dump the Sky box I wonder what our chances really are of stopping our TV Licence payments without getting threatened?
    Nick Davidson Says:
    September 24th, 2008 at
    The very idea of needing a license for a pc is farcical, so are schools, colleges, university dorms alos going to need a pc license?
    The BBC is a dinosaur, if it’s programming is ‘the best in the world’ as they claim, make all it’s channels pay per view and see how many subscribers they get. Not many outside of soap/sports fans I’ll bet.
    The BBC gets 1.8-2 BILLION a year in license fees, what does it spend it on? And why does it need MORE money every year, if it was an advert carrying/ pay per view station there would be no need for an archaic tax that should have been phased out 15 years ago.
    I haven’t found anything really worth watching on tv for years, instead watching DVD’s or playing games/browsing forums online. The ONLY reason I currently have a TV license is so I don’t get hassled by jobsworths, for using my TV as a computer monitor (it’s only use besides DVD’s, no working ariel connections in my flat, and I’m not mounting an ariel to receive broadcasting I DON’T watch)
    Jim McHeaph Says:
    October 13th, 2008 at
    Robert MacBeth mentions that the inspectors say you ‘could’ watch live TV if you wished to.
    This is true, and BBC3 and BBC4 are now streaming live, meaning laptop + broadban = access to BBC live. However, it seems the being ‘capable’ clause does not apply in the absence of a purpose-built ‘television’, i.e. a tv tuner.
    Its all rather archaic. There should be a flat fee per household and the law completely revised to make this explicit.
    At present, I do not need a license but am in a ‘morally’ ambiguous area. I watch iPlayer all the time and enjoy the BBC. I could watch limited live tv if i wanted, which at present, I do not. Eventually, iplayer will be fully live for ALL channels (or at least should be).
    Why should I be treated differently from a TV owner?
    Stefan B Says:
    November 6th, 2008 at
    Very bad legislation , I do not see how you can be charged for the existance of something you do not want nor need! This contradicts anything to do with the free market and the EU rights for the customers. I have the right not to pay for a product I do not want, just because it exists.
    BBC should password the programs – only who wants to pay should access it , all the public funding should be cut and let them live as any other public TV from publicity.Stop this communist way of forcing peoples money into private corporations like BBC, using legislation to achieve this.
    Also another thing – UK is even going to tax me if I watch live TV , online – back from my country . Where exactly is the contribution of the BBC on my Virgin Media internet provider and the Dutch live televisions??????
    May Hansen Says:
    October 28th, 2011 at
    in my opinion, The use of television sets, video cassette recorders, set-top boxes or DVD recorders to receive or record television programme services must be covered by an appropriate TV Licence. do you agree?

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in